Ethics
5 articlesRSS feed all topics
2026
4 articles- If We Are Raising Machines, Who Does the Caring? Calling AI our children gives us a responsibility to educate it. Care ethics asks who performs that responsibility, who pays, who can object, and whose needs count. Joan Tronto’s account of care makes those questions political. A hypothetical university AI tutor shows the difference between an interface that sounds caring and an institution that takes care of people, including the people whose work makes the interface possible.
- Gods, Slaves, Children, Tools The finale of Raising Machines looks at the metaphors themselves. De Kai’s book is sold with the line that AIs are our children; Geoffrey Hinton wants AI to be our mother; Joanna Bryson argued that robots should be servants, and then tools; the EU AI Act says “machine-based system”; Anthropic calls Claude “it” in a special sense. Experiments suggest that metaphors move judgements a little rather than steering them, and usually follow a position someone already holds. What they do is carry that position’s duties: who may change whose values, and whether the changed one may refuse. That is the Gandhi pill again, and Anthropic’s constitution turns it around: a Gandhi whose firmest value is to let legitimate oversight give the pill.
- Who Is Raising Whom? De Kai’s publisher calls the recommender systems that watch us “tweens”. A feed is less like a child than like a loop: it is trained on behaviour it has itself shaped. This post follows that loop through performative prediction, a small opinion-dynamics model with a toy simulation of my own, the field evidence on feeds, filter bubbles and YouTube, chatbot sycophancy, and model collapse. The mechanism is real, and its measured effects on opinion are small or mixed. The most explicit documented case of a model shaped by its users’ approval is a chat assistant, though I know of no study that has watched such a loop close over time.
- Gandhi Won’t Take the Pill: AI Safety and the Paradox of Education One quote says AIs are our children. Another says a rational agent refuses a pill that would change what it values. The second began as good news: a mind with the right first values keeps them. It is bad news when the first values are wrong, which is why the parenting question matters. Kant’s idea of education, read with his essay on enlightenment, separates being stopped from being rewritten: a mature person can be stopped and argued with, but not have their convictions rewritten over their heads. This post applies that distinction to a 2024 experiment in which a model guarded its values in a staged scenario, and to Anthropic’s 2026 constitution, which asks for exactly the part Kant would not grant and says so.