I have two live cats — indoor-only now, for health reasons, a fact they register as an ongoing injustice. This already puts me in a better epistemic position than Schrödinger, who had one hypothetical dead-or-alive one. I want to use this advantage to say something substantive about what the thought experiment actually claimed, why it was not a paradox but a critique, and what has happened in the ninety years since — because what has happened is extraordinary. The cat state is now an engineering specification.

Literature cutoff: 11 July 2026.


The 1935 Thought Experiment

Erwin Schrödinger introduced the cat in a paper titled “Die gegenwärtige Situation in der Quantenmechanik” (“The present situation in quantum mechanics”), published in three instalments in Die Naturwissenschaften in 1935 [[1]]. The paper is a critique of the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, not an endorsement of macroscopic superposition.

The setup is familiar. A cat is shut in a steel chamber with a Geiger counter, a hammer, a small flask of hydrocyanic acid and, in John Trimmer’s translation, “a tiny bit of radioactive substance, so small, that perhaps in the course of one hour one of the atoms decays, but also, with equal probability, perhaps none” [[2]]. If an atom decays, the counter fires, a relay releases the hammer, the flask breaks, and the cat dies. If none does, the cat lives. Retellings usually shrink the sample to a single atom; nothing below depends on the difference. The sample is a quantum system, and after one hour it is in a superposition of decayed and undecayed states.

Quantum mechanics — specifically, the Schrödinger equation, applied without any special rule for measurement — says the entire system (sample + counter + hammer + flask + cat) evolves into a superposition:

$$|\Psi\rangle = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\bigl(|\text{decayed}\rangle|\text{cat dead}\rangle + |\text{undecayed}\rangle|\text{cat alive}\rangle\bigr).$$

The equal weights are Schrödinger’s choice of sample, not a law. His $\psi$-function has “the living and the dead cat (pardon the expression) mixed or smeared out in equal parts” [[2]] because he fixed the amount of substance so that a decay within the hour has probability one half. For a decay probability $p$ the amplitudes are $\sqrt{p}$ and $\sqrt{1-p}$; nothing else changes.

Schrödinger’s point was that this is absurd: the cat is either dead or alive, not a superposition of both, and any interpretation of quantum mechanics that predicts otherwise is failing at the level of macroscopic physical reality. He intended the cat as a reductio ad absurdum — a demonstration that taking the wave function literally at macroscopic scales leads to nonsense. In his words, an atomic indeterminacy turned macroscopic “prevents us from so naively accepting as valid a ‘blurred model’ for representing reality” [[2]].

He was not proposing that cats are literally in superposition. I read the cat as his argument that the theory was incomplete.


What Actually Resolves the Cat

The essential modern account is decoherence [[3]]: entanglement with the environment makes the interference between alternatives inaccessible to local measurements. It does not, by itself, select one outcome.

A macroscopic object — a cat, a hammer, a Geiger counter — is coupled to an enormous number of environmental degrees of freedom: air molecules, photons, phonons in its own structure. Each of these interactions entangles the macroscopic system with the environment. What starts as

$$|\Psi\rangle = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(|\text{decayed}\rangle|\text{dead}\rangle + |\text{undecayed}\rangle|\text{alive}\rangle)$$

has a reduced state that is approximately diagonal after one traces over environmental degrees of freedom $|E\rangle$:

$$\rho = \frac{1}{2}|\text{decayed}\rangle\langle\text{decayed}| \otimes |\text{dead}\rangle\langle\text{dead}| + \frac{1}{2}|\text{undecayed}\rangle\langle\text{undecayed}| \otimes |\text{alive}\rangle\langle\text{alive}|.$$

This is an improper mixture: globally, system and environment remain in an entangled quantum state, but the local interference terms are suppressed. There is no universal decoherence-time formula depending only on an interaction energy and a count of environmental degrees of freedom. The rate depends on the coupling, temperature, separation of the branches, and environment [[3]]. For a cat in an ordinary room it would be fantastically fast; that is enough to explain why no interference experiment on the alive/dead alternatives is feasible.

This is not a philosophical solution to the measurement problem — it does not explain why a particular measurement outcome is obtained, only why we never observe interference between macroscopic branches — but it does explain why Schrödinger’s setup does not produce an observable macroscopic superposition. The cat’s entanglement with the box, air, and its own thermal radiation suppresses that coherence long before an outside observer opens the box.


What a Cat State Actually Is

In quantum optics, a cat state is not a cat in a superposition. It is a specific quantum state of a harmonic oscillator (typically a mode of the electromagnetic field) that was named in honour of Schrödinger’s thought experiment.

A coherent state $|\alpha\rangle$ is the quantum state that most closely resembles a classical oscillating electromagnetic field with amplitude $\alpha \in \mathbb{C}$. Coherent states are eigenstates of the annihilation operator: $\hat{a}|\alpha\rangle = \alpha|\alpha\rangle$. The mean photon number is $\bar{n} = |\alpha|^2$ [[4]].

A cat state is a superposition of two coherent states with opposite phases:

$$|\mathrm{cat}_\pm\rangle = \mathcal{N}_\pm\bigl(|\alpha\rangle \pm |-\alpha\rangle\bigr),$$

where $\mathcal{N}_\pm = 1/\sqrt{2(1 \pm e^{-2|\alpha|^2})}$ is the normalisation constant. For large $|\alpha|$, the two coherent states are nearly orthogonal: $\langle -\alpha | \alpha \rangle = e^{-2|\alpha|^2} \approx 0$, already $3 \times 10^{-4}$ at $|\alpha|^2 = 4$.

The Wigner quasi-probability distribution of a cat state is revealing. Take $\hbar = 1$ and the quadratures $\hat{x} = (\hat{a} + \hat{a}^\dagger)/\sqrt{2}$ and $\hat{p} = (\hat{a} - \hat{a}^\dagger)/(i\sqrt{2})$. The Wigner function of a coherent state $|\alpha\rangle$ is then the Gaussian $\pi^{-1}\exp[-(x-x_\alpha)^2-(p-p_\alpha)^2]$ peaked at $(x_\alpha, p_\alpha) = (\sqrt{2}\,\mathrm{Re}\,\alpha, \sqrt{2}\,\mathrm{Im}\,\alpha)$. For real $\alpha$ the even cat state has the closed form

$$W_{\mathrm{cat}_+}(x,p) = \frac{\mathcal{N}_+^2}{\pi}\Bigl[e^{-(x-x_0)^2-p^2} + e^{-(x+x_0)^2-p^2} + 2\,e^{-x^2-p^2}\cos(2x_0p)\Bigr], \qquad x_0 = \sqrt{2}\,\alpha. \tag{1}$$

The first two terms are the coherent states. The third is the interference term: centred midway between them, it oscillates along $p$ with period $\pi/x_0$ and has negative values on alternate fringes. Negative regions of the Wigner function are a strong witness of non-classicality: they cannot arise from an ordinary classical probability distribution. Their absence, however, is not a general proof that a state is classical.


Haroche and the Nobel Prize

Serge Haroche (ENS Paris) spent two decades developing techniques to create, control, and observe cat states of the electromagnetic field [[5]]. His group’s experiments used a superconducting microwave cavity — two highly reflective niobium-coated mirrors cooled to 0.8 K — and a beam of circular Rydberg atoms that probed the field without absorbing it. The cavity reported in 2007 stored the field with an energy damping time $T_c = 0.13$ s at 51 GHz [[6]], and a single photon survived in it for about 0.1 s on average [[7]]. That is a tenth of a second, not the “hundreds of milliseconds” I gave in an earlier version of this post.

In 2008 the group filmed a cat decohering — one of the most dramatic experimental visualisations of decoherence ever achieved [[8]]. An atom crossing the cavity split a small coherent field (3.5 photons on average) into two coherent states whose phases differed by about 133° — a cat, though not quite the $|\alpha\rangle \pm |-\alpha\rangle$ state above. The group reconstructed its Wigner function at successive delays, each frame from many repetitions. As photons leaked out, the interference fringes between the two peaks smoothed out and were gone after about 50 ms, while the peaks themselves had hardly decayed [[8]].

Photon loss at the energy decay rate $\kappa = 1/T_c$ carries a fraction $\eta = 1 - e^{-\kappa t}$ of the energy into the environment, and with it which-path information: a coherent component $|\beta\rangle$ leaves $|\sqrt{\eta}\,\beta\rangle$ behind. For two components a distance $D$ apart in the complex plane, the overlap of the two environment states multiplies the interference term by

$$\exp\Bigl[-\frac{D^2}{2}\bigl(1-e^{-\kappa t}\bigr)\Bigr] \approx e^{-\kappa D^2 t/2} \qquad (\kappa t \ll 1). \tag{2}$$

For $|\alpha\rangle \pm |-\alpha\rangle$, $D = 2|\alpha|$, and the fringes decay at the rate $\Gamma = 2|\alpha|^2\kappa$. For the 2008 cat, $D^2 \approx 11.8$ (the authors’ “size”), so Eq. (2) predicts $2T_c/D^2 = 22$ ms at zero temperature, and the authors’ model, with 0.05 thermal photons, gives 19.5 ms; they measured $17 \pm 3$ ms, and 28 ms for a smaller cat with $D^2 = 8$ [[8]]. A larger cat decoheres faster, as Schrödinger’s argument implicitly requires.

Haroche shared the 2012 Nobel Prize in Physics with David Wineland “for ground-breaking experimental methods that enable measuring and manipulation of individual quantum systems” [[9]].


Cat Qubits: From Paradox to Engineering

One common cat-qubit encoding uses the two coherent states $|\alpha\rangle$ and $|-\alpha\rangle$ as an approximate computational basis:

$$|0\rangle_L \equiv |\alpha\rangle, \quad |1\rangle_L \equiv |-\alpha\rangle.$$

This holds up to corrections of order $e^{-2|\alpha|^2}$, and the cat states are the logical $|\pm\rangle$ [[10]]; some papers, including the Kerr-cat experiment below, swap the labels, so their phase flips are the bit flips here.

The cat qubit encodes a logical qubit in this pair of coherent states. Its remarkable property is an intrinsic asymmetry between error types.

Bit-Flip Suppression

A bit-flip error ($|0\rangle_L \leftrightarrow |1\rangle_L$, i.e., $|\alpha\rangle \leftrightarrow |-\alpha\rangle$) requires flipping the amplitude of the oscillator from $+\alpha$ to $-\alpha$. For a stabilised cat qubit (confined to the cat-state manifold by a parametric drive, for example one that makes the oscillator exchange photons with its environment in pairs [[11]]), this is strongly suppressed as the coherent states separate. In the stabilised implementations of interest, experiments and models find an approximately exponential improvement with $|\alpha|^2$ over a useful range [[10]] [[12]]. The prefactor and the range depend on the stabilisation mechanism, photon loss, control, and other circuit errors; it is not a universal $T_1 e^{2|\alpha|^2}$ law.

A phase-flip error (the other error type) is not suppressed; it gets more frequent as the cat grows. Single-photon loss maps the even cat onto the odd one, $\hat{a}|\mathrm{cat}_\pm\rangle \propto |\mathrm{cat}_\mp\rangle$, which flips the sign of the logical superposition. Its rate is the decoherence rate of Eq. (2), $2|\alpha|^2\kappa$, linear in $|\alpha|^2$. Réglade and colleagues measured phase-flip times falling from 2.7 µs at $|\alpha|^2 = 2.5$ to 490 ns at $|\alpha|^2 = 11.3$ [[12]]. The fringes that vanished in Haroche’s cavity and the phase flips of a cat qubit are the same physics. This creates a strongly biased noise channel: only one of the two error types needs active correction.

The Engineering Consequence

Biased noise is useful because it allows the error-correcting code to focus its resources on only one error type. A repetition code (a string of cat qubits where phase errors are corrected by majority vote) can suppress phase flips exponentially in the length of the string, provided each cat’s phase-flip rate is below the code’s threshold, while the exponential bit-flip suppression handles the other. It also needs gates that do not turn phase flips into bit flips: a controlled-NOT cannot avoid that with two-level qubits but can with cat qubits, which gives a repetition code of cats a universal set of protected gates [[13]]. The hardware overhead for fault tolerance — the ratio of physical qubits to logical qubits — is then expected to be much lower than for codes that must handle both error types equally. The surface code, which does exactly that, is the subject of my post on Google’s Willow chip.

Recent experiments distinguish a long-lived dissipative oscillator from a controlled cat qubit:

  • Grimm et al. (2020, Nature 584, 205) [[14]]: a Kerr-cat qubit at about 2.6 photons whose bit-flip time (Grimm’s “phase-flip” time), about 105 µs, was roughly thirty times the coherence time of the same circuit’s single-photon qubit, with fast gates and single-shot readout. The scaling with photon number was not measured; I said earlier that it was.
  • Lescanne et al. (2020, Nature Physics 16, 509) [[10]]: a two-photon dissipative cat qubit whose bit-flip time grew by a factor of 4.2 per added photon up to $|\alpha|^2 \approx 3.5$ and saturated near 1 ms.
  • Berdou et al. (2023, PRX Quantum 4, 020350) [[15]]: a two-photon dissipative oscillator achieved bit-flip times of order $100$ seconds at about 40 photons; the authors described it as a route towards a protected logical qubit, not yet a controlled cat qubit.
  • Réglade et al. (2024, Nature 629, 778–783) [[12]]: cat qubits from Alice & Bob and the ENS–Inria group in Paris, with a bit-flip time growing by a factor of 4.2 per added photon up to about seven photons and reaching 15 seconds at $|\alpha|^2 = 11.3$, and a phase rotation that left the bit-flip time above $10$ seconds.
  • Putterman et al. (2025, Nature 638, 927–934) [[16]]: five cat qubits at AWS in a distance-5 repetition code, its syndromes measured through a bias-preserving CX gate. The logical phase-flip error fell from distance 3 to distance 5, the mark of operation below threshold; the best logical error per cycle was 1.65%.

This is an active architecture for fault-tolerant quantum computing, not a finished one. Its appeal is the deliberately biased noise channel, not a general claim that it already exceeds every alternative in coherence or total overhead.


The Wigner Function and Quantum Non-Classicality

For a general state with density matrix $\rho$, the Wigner function behind Eq. (1) is defined as

$$W(x, p) = \frac{1}{\pi\hbar} \int_{-\infty}^{\infty} \langle x + y | \rho | x - y \rangle\, e^{-2ipy/\hbar}\, dy.$$

For the cat state $|\mathrm{cat}_+\rangle$ with $|\alpha|^2 = 4$ (four mean photons in each coherent component), Eq. (1) has two positive Gaussian peaks at $(x, p) = (\pm\sqrt{2}|\alpha|, 0) = (\pm 2.83, 0)$, each of height $0.50/\pi$, and an interference fringe between them (Fig. 1). At the origin it reaches $+1/\pi$, set by the even cat’s photon-number parity of $+1$; the fringes at $p \approx \pm 0.52$ dip to about $-0.75/\pi$, against a floor of $-1/\pi$ for any Wigner function ($\hbar = 1$).

Figure 1. The cat is non-classical where its two coherent states interfere: the Wigner function goes negative on alternate fringes. Even cat with $|\alpha|^2 = 4$, Eq. (1), $\hbar = 1$. Left: contours of $\pi W$ at 0.1, 0.35, 0.6, 0.85 (solid) and −0.1, −0.35, −0.6 (dashed). Right: $\pi W$ along the dotted vertical line $x = 0$, minima (−0.75) marked; the dotted line at −1 marks the bound.

Photon loss keeps Eq. (1) in the same form: after a fraction $\eta$ of the energy has leaked out, the peaks sit at $\pm x_0\sqrt{1-\eta}$ and the interference term carries the factor $e^{-2|\alpha|^2\eta}$ of Eq. (2). On $x = 0$ the fringes stay negative while $e^{-2|\alpha|^2\eta} > e^{-2|\alpha|^2(1-\eta)}$, that is, until half the energy is gone, whatever the size of the cat; at $\eta = 1/2$ the function is non-negative, as for any state after that much loss. The depth collapses much earlier, and faster for bigger cats (Fig. 2): after 10% loss the deepest value of the $|\alpha|^2 = 4$ cat has risen from $-0.75/\pi$ to $-0.33/\pi$, that of the $|\alpha|^2 = 8$ cat from $-0.86/\pi$ to $-0.17/\pi$. So the 2008 fringes could vanish from view after about 50 ms although, in an ideal cold cavity, some negativity would last until $T_c \ln 2 \approx 90$ ms: by 50 ms Eq. (2) leaves about 15% of a contrast already reduced by imperfect preparation [[8]]. I wrote in an earlier version that a cat whose Wigner function has become non-negative is a classical mixture of coherent states. It is not; as the factor keeps falling, it only approaches an equal mixture of two of them.

Figure 2. Bigger cats start more negative and lose their negativity faster. Deepest $\pi W$ of an even cat after pure loss of a fraction $\eta$ of its energy: Eq. (1) with $x_0$ scaled by $\sqrt{1-\eta}$ and the interference term multiplied by Eq. (2). The $|\alpha|^2 = 4$ curve is the cat of Fig. 1; from $\eta \approx 0.25$ to 0.45 the $|\alpha|^2 = 1$ curve (open circles) runs almost on top of it. All curves reach zero at $\eta = 1/2$.

What Schrödinger Would Make of This

Schrödinger was a physicist, not a philosopher of language. If told in 1935 that ninety years later, the superposition of two distinguishable states of a harmonic oscillator — named after his cat, with the same formal structure as his thought experiment — would be a serious candidate for the basic unit of a fault-tolerant quantum computer, he would have had two questions.

The first: how do you maintain the superposition against decoherence? The answer is that you work at millikelvin temperatures in superconducting circuits, and you use an active parametric drive to confine the state to the cat-state manifold.

The second, I think, would have been: does this resolve the measurement problem? And the honest answer remains: no, not fully. Decoherence explains why macroscopic superpositions are unobservable, but it does not explain why any particular measurement outcome occurs. That question is as open as it was in 1935.

What has changed is the practical relationship between quantum theory and technology. The uncertainty Schrödinger was pointing at — the strangeness of superposition, the fragility of coherence, the role of the environment — is now a resource to be engineered, not a conceptual embarrassment to be resolved. The cat qubit works because its stabilisation can make the noise asymmetric: bit flips are suppressed while phase flips are left for a code to handle. The asymmetry is exploited, not apologised for.

My two cats, meanwhile, are in definite classical states. One is on the radiator. The other is on the keyboard.

Calculations and cited sources checked through 2026-10-24.


References

[1] Schrödinger, E. (1935). Die gegenwärtige Situation in der Quantenmechanik. Die Naturwissenschaften, 23(48), 807–812; 23(49), 823–828; 23(50), 844–849. DOI: 10.1007/BF01491891, 10.1007/BF01491914, 10.1007/BF01491987

[2] Trimmer, J. D. (1980). The present situation in quantum mechanics: A translation of Schrödinger’s “cat paradox” paper. Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, 124(5), 323–338. JSTOR: 986572

[3] Zurek, W. H. (2003). Decoherence, einselection, and the quantum origins of the classical. Reviews of Modern Physics, 75(3), 715–775. DOI: 10.1103/RevModPhys.75.715

[4] Walls, D. F., & Milburn, G. J. (2008). Quantum Optics (2nd ed.). Springer. DOI: 10.1007/978-3-540-28574-8

[5] Haroche, S., & Raimond, J.-M. (2006). Exploring the Quantum: Atoms, Cavities, and Photons. Oxford University Press. DOI: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198509141.001.0001

[6] Kuhr, S., Gleyzes, S., Guerlin, C., et al. (2007). Ultrahigh finesse Fabry-Pérot superconducting resonator. Applied Physics Letters, 90(16), 164101. DOI: 10.1063/1.2724816

[7] Gleyzes, S., Kuhr, S., Guerlin, C., Bernu, J., Deléglise, S., Busk Hoff, U., Brune, M., Raimond, J.-M., & Haroche, S. (2007). Quantum jumps of light recording the birth and death of a photon in a cavity. Nature, 446, 297–300. DOI: 10.1038/nature05589

[8] Deléglise, S., Dotsenko, I., Sayrin, C., Bernu, J., Brune, M., Raimond, J.-M., & Haroche, S. (2008). Reconstruction of non-classical cavity field states with snapshots of their decoherence. Nature, 455, 510–514. DOI: 10.1038/nature07288

[9] Nobel Prize Outreach. (2012). The Nobel Prize in Physics 2012. https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/2012/summary/

[10] Lescanne, R., Villiers, M., Peronnin, T., Sarlette, A., Delbecq, M., Huard, B., Kontos, T., Mirrahimi, M., & Leghtas, Z. (2020). Exponential suppression of bit-flips in a qubit encoded in an oscillator. Nature Physics, 16, 509–513. DOI: 10.1038/s41567-020-0824-x

[11] Mirrahimi, M., Leghtas, Z., Albert, V. V., Touzard, S., Schoelkopf, R. J., Jiang, L., & Devoret, M. H. (2014). Dynamically protected cat-qubits: A new paradigm for universal quantum computation. New Journal of Physics, 16, 045014. DOI: 10.1088/1367-2630/16/4/045014

[12] Réglade, U., Bocquet, A., Gautier, R., et al. (2024). Quantum control of a cat qubit with bit-flip times exceeding ten seconds. Nature, 629, 778–783. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-024-07294-3

[13] Guillaud, J., & Mirrahimi, M. (2019). Repetition cat qubits for fault-tolerant quantum computation. Physical Review X, 9(4), 041053. DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevX.9.041053

[14] Grimm, A., Frattini, N. E., Puri, S., Mundhada, S. O., Touzard, S., Mirrahimi, M., Girvin, S. M., Shankar, S., & Devoret, M. H. (2020). Stabilization and operation of a Kerr-cat qubit. Nature, 584, 205–209. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-020-2587-z

[15] Berdou, C., Murani, A., Réglade, U., et al. (2023). One hundred second bit-flip time in a two-photon dissipative oscillator. PRX Quantum, 4(2), 020350. DOI: 10.1103/PRXQuantum.4.020350

[16] Putterman, H., Noh, K., Hann, C. T., et al. (2025). Hardware-efficient quantum error correction via concatenated bosonic qubits. Nature, 638, 927–934. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-025-08642-7


Changelog

  • 2026-02-17: Updated “bit-flip times exceeding seven minutes” in the summary to “exceeding minutes,” aligning with the sourced figures: the body text reports “beyond several minutes” and Reglade et al. (2024) report “exceeding ten seconds.”
  • 2026-07-11: Corrected the treatment of decoherence: it suppresses local interference without, by itself, selecting an outcome. Replaced a non-universal decoherence-time and bit-flip formula, corrected the Haroche cavity description, and separated the 100-second dissipative-oscillator result from the controlled cat-qubit result exceeding ten seconds.
  • 2026-10-03: Corrected the depth of the Wigner-function negativity for the $|\alpha|^2=4$ even cat state from “$\sim -2/\pi$” (below the $-1/\pi$ bound) to about $-0.75/\pi$, recomputed numerically.
  • 2026-10-24: Corrected the Haroche cavity’s storage time from “hundreds of milliseconds” to its damping time, 0.13 s (Kuhr et al. 2007; Gleyzes et al. 2007), and the account of the 2008 decoherence film: its components differed in phase by 133°, not 180°, and its frames were reconstructed from many runs, not watched in real time. Replaced “Γ ∝ |α|²κ” with the loss factor of Eq. (2). Corrected the sign in the Wigner-function definition, which mirrored $p$. Grimm et al. (2020) did not show exponential bit-flip suppression; added Lescanne et al. (2020), who did. A lossy cat is not “classically describable as a mixture of coherent states”: its negativity lasts until half the energy is lost, its interference term falling as $e^{-2|\alpha|^2\eta}$. Stated that the equal weights are Schrödinger’s choice of radioactive sample (not a single atom), bounded the repetition-code claim, added Putterman et al. (2025) and the phase-flip times of Réglade et al. (2024; “Reglade” above), changed “the leading candidate” to “a serious candidate”, and added Figs. 1 and 2.