There Is No Such Thing as Full Accessibility — Only Barrier Reduction
Abstract
The German word ‘Barrierefreiheit’ promises freedom from barriers. That promise is structurally impossible. What we can achieve is Barrierearmut — a reduction of barriers. The difference is not semantic; it has consequences for policy, design, and institutional honesty.
Contents
The German compound Barrierefreiheit means, literally, freedom from barriers. It is the word used in legislation, in building codes, in institutional disability policies, in the guidelines that govern what universities must provide. It implies a completable state: you arrive at Barrierefreiheit, and you are done.
I want to argue that this is not only unachievable in practice — which most people in the field will readily concede — but structurally impossible in a society organised the way ours is. The honest term is Barrierearmut: poverty of barriers, reduction of barriers, a direction rather than a destination. The difference is not just linguistic. It shapes what we promise, what we measure, and what we allow ourselves to stop doing.
Two Models of Disability
The medical model of disability, which dominated institutional thinking for most of the twentieth century, locates the problem in the individual. A person is disabled by their impairment — by the deafness, the mobility limitation, the cognitive difference. The solution, in this frame, is treatment, cure, rehabilitation: changing the person to fit the world.
The social model, developed in the 1970s by disability activists — particularly through the work of the Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation in the UK — inverts this (UPIAS, 1976) [[1]]. The distinction is between impairment and disability. UPIAS defined impairment in bodily terms (“lacking part of or all of a limb, or having a defective limb, organ or mechanism of the body”) and disability as the disadvantage “caused by a contemporary social organisation which takes no or little account of people who have physical impairments” [[1]] (p. 14). Those definitions were written for physical impairment; later formulations, the UN Convention’s among them, extend the split to mental, intellectual and sensory impairments. A wheelchair user is not disabled by their legs; they are disabled by a building with no ramp. A deaf student is not disabled by their hearing; they are disabled by a lecture delivered without captioning.
Oliver (1990) [[2]] developed this into a full political framework. Disability is not a medical category but a social relation — a product of how societies organise space, communication, labour, and meaning. The implication is radical: to address disability, you do not fix the person; you change the society.
This model has transformed disability law, architecture, and educational policy. The UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD), adopted in 2006 and ratified by Germany in 2009, does not name a model, but its definition is relational, close to the social model’s. The preamble recognises “that disability results from the interaction between persons with impairments and attitudinal and environmental barriers”, and Article 1 speaks of impairments “which in interaction with various barriers may hinder” participation [[3]]. The disability-law scholar Theresia Degener reads the Convention as a human-rights model “which builds on the social model but develops it further” [[4]].
Germany’s Behindertengleichstellungsgesetz (BGG, the federal Disability Equality Act, which binds federal public bodies) follows the treaty closely. People with disabilities, in its § 3, are those with long-term impairments that, “in Wechselwirkung mit einstellungs- und umweltbedingten Barrieren” (in interaction with attitudinal and environmental barriers), can hinder their equal participation in society [[5]]. WCAG — the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines [[6]] — embodies the model for digital environments, in my reading; the guidelines themselves never mention it.
And yet.
The Limit of the Social Model
The social model is politically necessary and descriptively powerful. It is also incomplete.
Shakespeare and Watson (2001) [[7]] offer a careful critique: the strict social model, in its effort to relocate disability from body to society, ends up treating impairment as irrelevant — as a neutral fact that only becomes disabling through social organisation. But impairment is not neutral. Pain is real. Fatigue is real. Cognitive load is real. Some impairments impose limits that no architectural or digital intervention fully removes, because the limits are not externally imposed but intrinsic to how a particular nervous system processes the world.
The WHO’s International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF, 2001) [[8]] offers a biopsychosocial synthesis: disability as an interaction between health condition, body function and structure, activity, participation, and contextual factors (both environmental and personal). This is less politically clean than the social model — it does not attribute all disablement to society — but it is more honest about the complexity. WHO’s own introduction to the ICF puts it plainly: “On their own, neither model is adequate, although both are partially valid” [[9]].
The point is not to retreat from the social model’s insights but to acknowledge that “removing all barriers” is an incomplete goal even in its own terms. Impairment is real; context is transformable; and the interaction between them is irreducibly particular. There is no single intervention that produces accessibility for everyone.
Why Barrierefreiheit Is a False Promise
The legal definition makes the promise precise. Under § 4 BGG, buildings, vehicles, information systems and other designed environments are barrierefrei “wenn sie für Menschen mit Behinderungen in der allgemein üblichen Weise, ohne besondere Erschwernis und grundsätzlich ohne fremde Hilfe auffindbar, zugänglich und nutzbar sind”: if people with disabilities can find, access and use them in the usual way, without particular difficulty and in principle without help from others [[5]].
Consider what full accessibility would require. It would require physical spaces that accommodate every mobility profile, every sensory profile, every energy and endurance pattern. It would require information architectures that are simultaneously navigable by users with very different cognitive and perceptual systems. It would require communication norms, cultural contexts, and institutional practices that do not privilege any particular neurotype, any particular communication style, any particular relationship to time and deadlines and social convention.
None of that is achievable in a society with the historical sediment ours has. Our cities were built for able-bodied adults with average sensory capacity and without requirement for cognitive accessibility. Our universities were built — institutionally, not just physically — for a particular kind of learner with a particular kind of background, deploying a particular kind of intelligence. Retrofitting accessibility onto these structures is possible, valuable, and necessary. But it is not the same as having built for full human variation from the start. The ramp bolted onto the side of the neoclassical building solves the wheelchair problem and leaves everything else intact.
Kafer (2013) [[10]] makes a more radical version of this argument. The concept of “normal” function — the standard against which accessibility is measured — is not neutral. It encodes a history of who was considered the default human, and who was considered an exception requiring accommodation. Achieving “accessibility” within a framework that still treats certain bodies and minds as exceptions to be accommodated does not escape that framework; it manages it.
This is why a building can pass every accessibility audit and still function as an excluding institution. The audit measures physical features. It does not measure whether disabled students are welcomed into the culture of the institution, whether their modes of participation are genuinely valued, whether the hidden curriculum of “how to be a student” is legible to someone whose processing differs from the assumed default.
What Barrierearmut Means
If Barrierefreiheit is the impossible promise, Barrierearmut — barrier reduction — is the honest goal. It is not lesser. It is more accurate.
Barrier reduction as a framework asks: which barriers, for which people, with which effects, can be reduced through which interventions, at what cost, with what trade-offs? It treats accessibility as an ongoing practice rather than a checkable state. It acknowledges that every design decision — physical, digital, institutional — makes some things easier for some people and harder for others, and that the question is always whose needs are centred and whose are treated as exceptions.
Universal Design (Mace, 1985) [[11]] moves in this direction: designing from the start for the broadest range of users, rather than designing for the norm and retrofitting for exceptions. A kerb cut is the standard example — designed for wheelchair users, also useful for people with pushchairs, luggage, bicycles, temporary injuries. But Universal Design, honestly applied, acknowledges that no design is truly universal. Every design embeds assumptions. The honest goal is to minimise the distance between those assumptions and the actual diversity of users.
Where Universal Design Stops
The kerb cut is also the standard counterexample. A blind pedestrian finds the edge of the carriageway with the long cane, and the kerb that a wheelchair cannot climb is the kerb that tells the cane where the pavement ends. The Rhineland-Palatinate road authority’s design guide puts it in two sentences: a 6 cm kerb, a good height for the cane, is for wheelchair users “ein nahezu unüberwindbares Hindernis” (an almost insurmountable obstacle), while the 0 cm that is ideal for them can endanger blind and partially sighted people, who no longer feel where the road begins [[12]] (p. 6).
The standard DIN 18040-3, in its 2014 edition (still listed as current in October 2026, beside a 2023 draft [[13]]), has two answers. The separate crossing gives each group its own strip: a kerb of at least 6 cm for blind and partially sighted people and, beside it, a kerb lowered to road level for wheelchair and rollator users, normally no wider than 1 m and marked off by a field of tactile paving. The shared crossing lowers the whole kerb to 3 cm with an edge rounded to a 20 mm radius, meant to serve wheelchair and rollator users and blind people at once [[14]]; the Rhineland-Palatinate guide reserves it for light traffic or tight space [[12]] (p. 22). I have not read the standard; the values are as quoted in [[14]] and [[12]].
Fig. 1 shows how tight that compromise is. The heights that work for each group meet at a single value, and 3 cm is the limit of both: “gerade noch” (only just) passable for a wheelchair, with effort, and only just detectable with the cane, with high concentration [[12]] (pp. 6, 20).
The separate crossing, which the guide prefers wherever possible, does better by giving up on a single design. It needs pavement width that not every street has, and its level strip is normally kept to 1 m and marked off, because a wider one is a hazard for blind pedestrians who may step into the road unawares [[12]] (pp. 21–23). Both designs are good barrier reduction: negotiated settlements between two groups’ needs, not the removal of barriers.
The CRPD’s own definition builds the limit in: universal design means designing products and environments “to be usable by all people, to the greatest extent possible”, and it “shall not exclude assistive devices for particular groups of persons with disabilities where this is needed” (Art. 2) [[3]]. The federal trunk-road act asks those who build federal roads to aim at “möglichst weitreichende Barrierefreiheit”, as much freedom from barriers as possible (§ 3(1) FStrG) [[15]]. The duty is graded. Only the noun promises an end state.
For digital environments this is particularly visible, and the standard says so itself. WCAG 2.2 defines four principles — Perceivable, Operable, Understandable, Robust — and testable success criteria. Its introduction states that the guidelines “are not able to address the needs of people with all types, degrees, and combinations of disability”, and its conformance section concedes that “it is not possible to satisfy all Level AAA success criteria for some content” [[6]]. Meeting a stated WCAG 2.2 conformance level is meaningful, but conformance claims have scope, testing and technology assumptions; they are not evidence that every user can access every task. WCAG 3.0 remains a W3C Working Draft (latest version 10 September 2026), not a conformance standard [[16]]. The standards improve; the gap remains.
Institutional Honesty
I work in a university. Universities have accessibility offices, procedures, documentation requirements. A student with a disability can request accommodations: extended exam time, written materials in accessible formats, individual arrangements. These accommodations are real and valuable. They are also, structurally, a system for managing exceptions to a norm that the institution has no intention of revising.
The student who needs extended time is asking the institution to adjust its standard procedure for their case. The institution does so, often generously. But the standard procedure — the timed exam, the lecture format, the office-hours model — remains the standard. The exception is granted; the norm persists. This is barrier management, not barrier reduction.
Barrier reduction would mean asking, as a matter of institutional practice: what is the actual pedagogical purpose of the timed exam, and are there better ways to assess that competency that do not exclude students whose processing differs? It would mean asking what the lecture format assumes about the listener, and whether those assumptions are necessary. These questions are uncomfortable because they challenge practices that are also convenient, and because the people who benefit from the current norms are the ones with the institutional power to change them.
This is not a problem unique to universities. It is the general structure of the problem.
A Direction, Not a Destination
I am not arguing for giving up on accessibility work. The opposite. I am arguing that naming the goal honestly — barrier reduction, not barrier freedom — produces better practice than the false promise of an achievable endpoint.
Barrierefreiheit as a legal standard can be met by a compliant building that is still a hostile institution. Barrierearmut as a practice requires continuous attention to who is being excluded and by what, and ongoing effort to reduce that exclusion knowing that it will never be complete.
That is harder. It does not allow the institution to certify itself as done. It requires asking the uncomfortable questions about whose default is encoded in the design — a question that leads, quickly, to the question of privilege.
That is the next post: The Invisible Entrance Fee: On Privilege, Education, and the Institutions That Reproduce Both.
Standards and legal sources checked through 2026-10-28.
References
[1] UPIAS and The Disability Alliance (1976). Fundamental Principles of Disability. Union of the Physically Impaired Against Segregation, London, November 1976. UPIAS’s definitions of impairment and disability are on p. 14 of the original. Reformatted edition, Leeds Disability Archive, 1997: https://disability-studies.leeds.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/40/library/UPIAS-fundamental-principles.pdf
[2] Oliver, M. (1990). The Politics of Disablement. Macmillan. DOI: 10.1007/978-1-349-20895-1
[3] United Nations General Assembly (2006). Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (A/RES/61/106, adopted 13 December 2006, in force 3 May 2008). Preamble (e), Articles 1 and 2. https://www.un.org/disabilities/documents/convention/convoptprot-e.pdf; status and ratifications: https://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=TREATY&mtdsg_no=IV-15&chapter=4&clang=_en
[4] Degener, T. (2016). Disability in a human rights context. Laws, 5(3), 35. Open access, CC BY 4.0. DOI: 10.3390/laws5030035
[5] Gesetz zur Gleichstellung von Menschen mit Behinderungen (Behindertengleichstellungsgesetz, BGG) of 27 April 2002, last amended by Article 7 of the Act of 23 May 2022, §§ 1, 3 and 4. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgg/
[6] W3C (2023). Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2. W3C Recommendation, first published 5 October 2023; edition of 12 December 2024 consulted. https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG22/
[7] Shakespeare, T. & Watson, N. (2001). The social model of disability: an outdated ideology? In Exploring Theories and Expanding Methodologies: Where We Are and Where We Need to Go (Research in Social Science and Disability, Vol. 2, pp. 9–28). JAI. DOI: 10.1016/S1479-3547(01)80018-X
[8] World Health Organization (2001). International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF). World Health Organization.
[9] World Health Organization (2002). Towards a Common Language for Functioning, Disability and Health: ICF (WHO/EIP/GPE/CAS/01.3), p. 9. World Health Organization, Geneva. https://cdn.who.int/media/docs/default-source/classification/icf/icfbeginnersguide.pdf
[10] Kafer, A. (2013). Feminist, Queer, Crip. Indiana University Press. DOI: 10.2979/6841.0
[11] Mace, R.L. (1985). Universal Design: Barrier Free Environments for Everyone. Designers West, 33(1), 147–152.
[12] Landesbetrieb Mobilität Rheinland-Pfalz (2020). Leitfaden für die barrierefreie Gestaltung von Verkehrsflächen (01/2020). Koblenz, 8 January 2020. Sections 3.3 (p. 6), 4.2.2 (p. 20), 5.1 (pp. 21–22) and 5.1.1 (p. 23); page numbers as printed in the guide. https://lbm.rlp.de/fileadmin/lbm/Themen/Strassenplanung/Dokumente/Leitfaden_Barrierefreiheit_01_2020.pdf
[13] DIN Media. Catalogue entries for DIN 18040-3:2014-12 Barrierefreies Bauen – Planungsgrundlagen – Teil 3: Öffentlicher Verkehrs- und Freiraum (marked current; partly replaced by DIN EN 17210:2021-08) and for the draft DIN 18040-3:2023-01 (published 2 December 2022). Checked 28 October 2026. https://www.dinmedia.de/de/norm/din-18040-3/223713891; https://www.dinmedia.de/de/norm-entwurf/din-18040-3/361016749
[14] Der Landesbehindertenbeauftragte der Freien Hansestadt Bremen (2018). Stellungnahme des Landesbehindertenbeauftragten zum NVZ Oberneuland, 16 May 2018, quoting DIN 18040-3:2014-12, clauses 5.3.2.1 and 5.3.2.2. https://www.behindertenbeauftragter.bremen.de/sixcms/media.php/13/2018-05-16%20Stellungnahme%20.pdf
[15] Bundesfernstraßengesetz (FStrG), § 3(1). https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/fstrg/__3.html
[16] W3C (2026). W3C Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 3.0. W3C Working Draft, 10 September 2026. https://www.w3.org/TR/wcag-3.0/
Changelog
- 2025-11-05: Corrected the Mace reference from (1997) Designers West 44(1) to (1985) Designers West 33(1), 147–152. The year 1997 relates to the separate “Principles of Universal Design” publication by Connell, Jones, Mace et al. at NC State, not the Designers West article.
- 2026-07-11: Clarified that WCAG 2.2 conformance is scoped and test-dependent rather than proof of universal access, and that WCAG 3.0 remains a draft.
- 2026-10-03: Corrected the in-text citation “Mace, 1997” to “Mace, 1985” so it matches the reference list (corrected on 2025-11-05 but not in the body). WCAG 3.0 re-checked: still a W3C Working Draft (10 September 2026).
- 2026-10-28: Corrected the claim that the UN Convention is “explicitly built on” the social model: the treaty names no model; its preamble (e) and Article 1 define disability relationally, through the interaction of impairments and barriers (now quoted), and Degener (2016) reads it as a human-rights model that builds on the social model. Corrected the UPIAS definition of impairment from “a physical or cognitive difference” to UPIAS’s own wording, which concerns physical impairment only. Glossed the Behindertengleichstellungsgesetz (BGG) and replaced “draws on it” with its § 3 definition of disability; added its § 4 definition of Barrierefreiheit and the graded duty in § 3(1) FStrG (“möglichst weitreichende Barrierefreiheit”). Marked the sentence on WCAG and the social model as my reading, since WCAG does not mention the model. Added a section on the kerb-height conflict between wheelchair and long-cane users at crossings, with Fig. 1: the separate crossing (0 cm beside at least 6 cm) and the shared 3 cm crossing of DIN 18040-3 (2014 edition), as quoted by the Bremen state disability commissioner and described in the Rhineland-Palatinate road authority’s 2020 guide; the standard itself was not consulted, and the figure’s bands are my reading of the guide. Added WCAG 2.2’s own statements that it cannot meet every need and that Level AAA cannot be met for all content, the CRPD’s definition of universal design, and WHO’s introduction to the ICF on the two models. Changed Shakespeare and Watson from 2002 to 2001, the year the University of Glasgow repository gives, and added DOIs. Converted the references to a numbered list with inline markers. WCAG 3.0 re-checked: still a W3C Working Draft (10 September 2026).