This post describes “Mission to Mars: Concept and Implementation of a Design-Based (Hands-On) Smartphone Experiment Helping Students Understand the Effects Caused by Differences in Air Pressure”, published in The Physics Teacher (Vol. 60, 2022) together with Alexander Küpper and André Bresges [[1]].


The Problem With Air Pressure

Air pressure is one of those topics that students nominally know something about from everyday life while still using explanations that conflict with the physics. The education literature documents recurring ideas. Earlier studies, reviewed by Bulunuz, Jarrett and Bulunuz [[2]], found that still air has little reality for many children, who describe air as wind or sky; that children credit air with pushing only when it moves or is heated (Séré); and that they explain a vacuum as something that “sucks” or “pulls” rather than as a region into which the surrounding air pushes (Brook and Driver). An essay from a project on children’s ideas about matter adds that air “doesn’t have heft or appear to take up any space” for them [[3]]: it seems to weigh nothing and to be nothing. Altitude is less clear-cut. Before an intervention in a US study, 46% of 57 trainee and first-year primary teachers explained correctly why the ears clog on a fast drive downhill and 35% the lower boiling point on a mountain [[4]]; most of the Turkish middle-school pupils in [[2]] answered the same two items correctly (67% and 57%).

Some of these misconceptions are stubborn precisely because everyday experience seems to support them. Air does not feel like it has weight. A vacuum cleaner does feel like it is pulling. The atmosphere, experienced from inside it, does not announce itself as a pressure source.

The standard approach to this material — explaining atmospheric pressure, defining $p = F/A$, working through barometric altitude formulae — addresses the conceptual gaps at the declarative level. Students can recite that air exerts pressure in all directions. Whether they have actually updated their mental model is a different question.

“Mission to Mars” is a design-based attempt to make those explanations testable through a physical encounter with pressure differences. The published paper describes the intervention; it is not a controlled study of conceptual change.


The Context: Why Mars?

The motivation for choosing the Mars context was empirical, not poetic. The international ROSE survey reported substantial interest in space and astronomy items [[5]], although the rankings vary by country, item, and gender. That is a reason to test an astronomical context, not evidence that it motivates every class or improves learning by itself.

“Mission to Mars” asks students: a crewed mission to Mars would travel through the vacuum of space, with the crew living in a pressurised compartment. The compartment has to maintain atmospheric pressure while surrounded by near-vacuum. What happens if it fails? And how would you design a spacecraft structure to prevent that failure? Arrival does not remove the problem: the surface pressure on Mars is 6.36 hPa at the mean radius, varying from 4.0 to 8.7 hPa with the season, under 1% of Earth’s [[6]], so a compartment at 1013 hPa still carries about 99% of the pressure difference it had in space.

The question is concrete. The physics behind it — the difference between the pressure inside the compartment and the near-zero pressure outside, and the forces this pressure difference exerts on any structure — is the content of the lesson.


The Experiment

The full version of the experiment, as we ran it at the astro-lab at the University of Cologne, uses a vacuum pump, a bell jar, and a smartphone running phyphox [[7]]. The barometer that records the pressure as the pump evacuates the jar is either a compatible smartphone’s built-in sensor, which puts the phone itself in the chamber and under the safety conditions below, or an external sensor box that sends its readings to phyphox (see the design step). Not every phone exposes a pressure sensor to phyphox; the hardware must be checked before the lesson, or replaced by a rated external sensor.

Before building anything, students verify that the smartphone is a functional pressure gauge: they measure the current atmospheric pressure in the room and compare it with a provided reference value. This step matters pedagogically — it establishes that the phone is a real scientific instrument, not just a device for receiving worksheets.

Then comes the design-build-test cycle:

Design: Students are given PVC plumbing pipe sections, empty food containers, resealable bags, rubber bands, clamps, and other household materials. Their task is to build a prototype “spaceship” — a container that will maintain near-atmospheric pressure inside while the bell jar around it is evacuated to low pressure. A pressure sensor goes inside the prototype to measure whether the prototype is holding. In our paper’s notes we name two options: a retired or second-hand phone, or an external sensor box [[1]]. The box is, as far as the notes show, TI’s CC2650 SensorTag: they cite its design guide and link a phyphox configuration file for it, and it sends its readings over Bluetooth [[8]]. Only the sensor box keeps the phone outside the chamber; a phone inside the prototype is under reduced pressure as soon as the prototype fails, and falls under the safety conditions below.

Predict: Before testing, students are asked to state why they think their prototype will or won’t work. This surfaces their preconceptions in a low-stakes way and sets up the next stage.

Test: The prototype goes into the bell jar. The pump runs. The pressure sensor records. The light curve — sorry, the pressure curve — tells the story. In our implementation, traces included the following; Fig. 1 shows simulated versions of the first three.

  • Nearly flat line: over the duration and resolution of the test, pressure inside stays near atmospheric. That is evidence of no detected leak, not proof of perfect airtightness.
  • Step drop (the “bathtub” curve): a visible failure event — a cap pops off, and the pressure inside falls almost at once to the chamber pressure, then follows it. Students hear the pop. They did not expect the pop. This is the moment.
  • Gradual decay: the prototype leaks slowly, the pressure inside drops steadily. Invisible failure. After venting, it refills slowly through the same leak.
  • Noisy signal: a result requiring a sensor, seal, sampling, and setup check before interpretation.

The “bathtub” name presumably describes the shape of the whole failure record: a steep wall, a low stretch that follows the chamber down while the pump runs, and a second wall when the chamber is vented (Fig. 1). It is not the reliability engineer’s bathtub curve of failure rate against time.

The low end of a failure trace needs a caution. The SensorTag’s barometer is a Bosch BMP280 [[8]], specified for 300 to 1100 hPa with a typical absolute accuracy of ±1 hPa near sea-level pressure. The bare chip’s absolute maximum rating runs from 0 to 20,000 hPa [[9]], so vacuum is within what the chip itself is rated to survive; that rating says nothing about the board, its coin cell or a phone around it. Below 300 hPa the readings are outside the specification, so a trace that falls that far shows that the prototype failed, not what the chamber’s final pressure was. A phone’s barometer has its own data sheet and its own limits.

Figure 1. A lid failure shows as a step and a leak as a slope, and both can take the reading below the range the sensor is specified for. Simulated, not measured: inside pressure of a sealed prototype, of one whose lid lets go when the pressure difference reaches 500 hPa, and of one with a slow leak, from a first-order leak model, $\mathrm{d}p_\mathrm{in}/\mathrm{d}t = -(p_\mathrm{in} - p_\mathrm{out})/\tau$, with $\tau \to \infty$ for the sealed prototype and for the lid until it lets go, 0.3 s after that, and 45 s for the leak. From 10 s the chamber (dotted) is pumped from 1013 hPa towards 30 hPa with a time constant of 15 s; at 130 s it is vented with a time constant of 3 s. These parameters are illustrative, and real leaks through narrow gaps are not linear. The shaded band is not simulated: it marks pressures below 300 hPa, the lower limit of the BMP280’s specified range [[9]].

The PVC pipe trap: in our apparatus, an impressive-looking push-fit PVC assembly could fail when the force from the pressure difference exceeded the lid’s retention. The net pressure force on the lid is

$$F = (p_\mathrm{in} - p_\mathrm{out})\,A = \Delta p\,\frac{\pi d^2}{4}, \tag{1}$$

where $p_\mathrm{in}$ and $p_\mathrm{out}$ are the pressures inside the prototype and in the chamber, $\Delta p$ is their difference, $A$ is the area enclosed by the seal and $d$ its diameter. With the chamber fully evacuated, $\Delta p$ approaches one atmosphere, 1013 hPa, and a lid 8 cm across, about the size of a jam-jar lid, carries $F \approx 509$ N, the weight of a 52 kg mass. The force grows with the square of the diameter, so a wide pipe end is harder to hold than a jar lid at the same pressure (Fig. 2). Whether a given lid lets go depends on the geometry, seal, pressure history, and fastening; PVC is not intrinsically the wrong material. Students rebuild.

Figure 2. A lid is pushed open from inside, not pulled from outside, and the push quickly reaches hundreds of newtons. (a) Forces on a push-fit cap at the moment it lets go, drawn to scale for 1013 hPa inside and 513 hPa in the chamber: the inside air pushes outward with $p_\mathrm{in}A$, the remaining chamber air pushes inward with $p_\mathrm{out}A$, and friction on the skirt, $F_\mathrm{r}$, makes up the difference. (b) Net pressure force from Eq. (1) against lid diameter for three pressure differences; the marked values are for an illustrative 8 cm lid.

The Misconceptions, Addressed

The design-test-rebuild cycle is intended to make the misconceptions listed above discussable against measurements:

Air is empty/weightless: approached in pre-activities with standard demonstrations (the dunked napkin, the deflated-vs-inflated balloon). The balloon comparison needs care: weighed in air, the balloon is buoyed up by the air it displaces, so the balance registers only the small excess mass of the slightly compressed air inside, not the mass of all the air in the balloon.

Air only exerts pressure when moving: the bell jar demonstration makes this concrete — the sensor shows pressure even in a static, undisturbed volume. When the pump evacuates the jar, the pressure falls because air is removed; once the pump stops, the remaining air no longer flows but keeps its lower, non-zero pressure. Pressure comes from the random motion of the molecules, which never stops, not from the air moving as a whole.

A vacuum sucks: this is the crucial one. A lid failure can make the force direction visible. The lid does not get sucked outward. The air inside the prototype at near-atmospheric pressure pushes the lid open against the external near-vacuum (Fig. 2). When the lid fails and students hear the rush of air flowing back in after the valve is opened, the direction of the pressure force can become clear: the net force follows the pressure difference across the lid. It did not become clear to every student; some kept the language of a vacuum pulling, as I describe in the follow-up on research methods.

The inquiry is scaffolded through worksheets and index cards. In the lab version, trained staff operate a rated chamber and pump, inspect the apparatus, keep people clear of the failure path, and set limits appropriate to the chamber, sensor, and device. No phone, including a retired one, should be put under reduced pressure unless its manufacturer permits it and a documented risk assessment covers the device, battery, chamber, and likely failure modes. Apple, for example, specifies the iPhone 15 only as “tested up to 10,000 feet (3000 m)” [[10]], about 700 hPa in the standard atmosphere and far above the pressure in an evacuated bell jar. For that phone the condition is not met. The sensor box keeps the phone outside the chamber and so avoids the question for the phone; the box itself, with its coin cell, still belongs in the risk assessment.


What Can Safely Be Varied

The published implementation explored apparatus at different cost levels, but cost is not a safety specification. Household food containers, improvised bell jars, and vacuum cleaners are not substitutes for pressure-rated equipment: containers may buckle or fragment, hoses and lids may become projectiles, and consumer pumps are not designed as laboratory vacuum systems.

For a school implementation, the vacuum side should therefore remain a supervised demonstration using a rated chamber, compatible pump, gauge, shield where required, and the institution’s risk assessment. Students can still own the intellectual work: predict the pressure curve, design and inspect a model, analyse supplied or remotely displayed data, explain a failure, and revise the design. A low-budget or remote version can use recorded datasets rather than an improvised pressure vessel at home.


A Note on Where This Fits

“Mission to Mars” grew out of the astro-lab at the University of Cologne, the same student laboratory context as the exoplanet transit experiments [[11]]. The common thread is not the specific physics topic (air pressure here, photometry there) but the experimental approach: smartphones as real measurement instruments, everyday materials as apparatus, an astronomical context that sustains engagement, and a design-build-test cycle that forces students to encounter the physics physically rather than only propositionally.

The air pressure content connects naturally to the exoplanet unit at a curriculum level: habitability of exoplanets depends partly on atmospheric pressure. In the Fremde Welten article, atmospheric pressure is listed as one of the factors that determine whether a detected exoplanet could support life — an explicit cross-link between the two units.

The astro-lab@home post describes how the broader astro-lab programme — including this experiment — was adapted for home use during the pandemic. The air-pressure experiment is among the more challenging to replicate at home; the safe remote adaptation is to analyse a supervised live demonstration or a recorded trace, not to improvise a vacuum chamber.

The design-build-test structure of this experiment also ended up at the centre of a methodological argument during my thesis work. The short version: everyone told me to use grounded theory instead of design thinking as the research framework, and they were right to do so. That story is in a separate post.


Experiment and literature record checked through 2026-10-24.

References

[1] Spicker, S. J., Küpper, A., & Bresges, A. (2022). Mission to Mars: Concept and implementation of a design-based (hands-on) smartphone experiment helping students understand the effects caused by differences in air pressure. The Physics Teacher, 60(1), 47–50. DOI: 10.1119/10.0009109

[2] Bulunuz, M., Jarrett, O. S., & Bulunuz, N. (2009). Middle school students’ conceptions on physical properties of air. Journal of Turkish Science Education, 6(1), 37–49. https://tused.org/index.php/tused/article/download/105/63/133

[3] Smith, C. L. (n.d.). The child’s ideas for grade 5, 4: Air, a gas [essay]. The Inquiry Project, TERC. Opened 24 October 2026. https://inquiryproject.terc.edu/curriculum/teacher/child_and_scientist/carol5_4.cfm.html

[4] Bulunuz, M., & Jarrett, O. S. (2009). Undergraduate and masters students’ understanding about properties of air and the forms of reasoning used to explain air phenomena. Asia-Pacific Forum on Science Learning and Teaching, 10(2), Article 2. https://www.eduhk.hk/apfslt/v10_issue2/bulunuz/index.htm

[5] Sjøberg, S., & Schreiner, C. (2010). The ROSE project: An overview and key findings. University of Oslo.

[6] Williams, D. R. Mars fact sheet. NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, last updated 19 May 2025. Opened 24 October 2026. https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/marsfact.html

[7] Staacks, S., Hütz, S., Heinke, H., & Stampfer, C. (2018). Advanced tools for smartphone-based experiments: phyphox. Physics Education, 53(4), 045009. DOI: 10.1088/1361-6552/aac05e

[8] Texas Instruments (2015). Multi-Standard CC2650 SensorTag Design Guide (TIDU862). https://www.ti.com/lit/ug/tidu862/tidu862.pdf

[9] Bosch Sensortec (2021). BMP280 digital pressure sensor, data sheet BST-BMP280-DS001-26, revision 1.26. https://www.bosch-sensortec.com/media/boschsensortec/downloads/datasheets/bst-bmp280-ds001.pdf

[10] Apple. iPhone 15 – Tech Specs. Opened 24 October 2026. https://support.apple.com/en-us/111831

[11] Küpper, A., & Schulz, A. (2017). Schülerinnen und Schüler auf der Suche nach der Erde 2.0 im Schülerlabor der Universität zu Köln. Astronomie+Raumfahrt im Unterricht, 54(1) (no. 157), 40–45.


Changelog

  • 2025-10-03: Updated the self-citation to the correct year (2022), volume/issue (60(1)), pages (47–50), and DOI (10.1119/10.0009109).
  • 2026-07-11: Added the literature cutoff and clarified in the research note that device sensors, vacuum level and learning outcomes depend on the specific implementation.
  • 2026-07-11: Recast the classroom outcomes as implementation observations, corrected the pressure-force and sensor limits, and removed unsafe instructions for improvised home vacuum systems.
  • 2026-10-03: Corrected the publication details in the opening note and summary from “Vol. 59, 2021” to Vol. 60, 2022, matching the reference list and the DOI record (The Physics Teacher 60(1), 47–50).
  • 2026-10-24: Made the design step consistent with the safety paragraph: it said “the phone (or external sensor) goes inside the prototype”, while the safety paragraph ruled out putting a personal phone under reduced pressure. The design step now gives the two options named in our paper’s notes, a retired phone or an external sensor box (as far as the notes show, a TI SensorTag), and says that only the box keeps the phone outside the chamber; the safety rule now covers any phone, including a retired one, and the summary mentions the sensor box. Renamed the “bathtub” trace a step drop and noted that the nickname describes a shape, not the reliability engineer’s failure-rate curve. Cited each idea in the misconception list to the study or review that reports it, and replaced “pressure increases with height”, which I could not source, with the mixed results of two studies on pressure and altitude. Clarified the still-air explanation: pressure comes from the random motion of the molecules, not from the air moving as a whole. Added simulated traces, Fig. 1; the net pressure force on a lid, Eq. (1), with a worked value (509 N on an 8 cm lid at one atmosphere of difference) and Fig. 2; the Mars surface pressure (6.36 hPa at the mean radius); the BMP280’s specified range (300–1100 hPa) and what it means for the low end of a failure trace; the buoyancy caveat for the balloon demonstration; and Apple’s 3000 m operating-altitude specification. Changed “the direction of the pressure force becomes clear” to “can become clear”, in line with the follow-up post, where not every student read the lid failure that way. Converted the references to numbered entries and corrected “Sjoberg” to Sjøberg.