Literature and publication status checked through 2026-10-28. This is a retrospective interpretation of an unusually fast episode, not a quantitative study of all replication activity or media coverage.

July 22, 2023

On Saturday, 22 July 2023, two preprints were submitted to arXiv, a little over two hours apart [[1]] [[2]]. They entered arXiv’s public listing on Tuesday, 25 July [[3]]. They came from Sukbae Lee, Ji-Hoon Kim and colleagues at the Quantum Energy Research Centre, a Seoul start-up, with co-authors at universities and institutes in Korea and the United States, and they claimed something that condensed matter physicists have been chasing for over a century: a material that superconducts at room temperature and ambient pressure.

The compound was called LK-99. It was a copper-doped lead apatite, made in solid-state steps from lead oxide, lead sulfate, copper and phosphorus (first lanarkite, Pb₂SO₅, and copper phosphide, Cu₃P, then the two together at 925 °C) [[1]], a procedure that, on paper, any moderately equipped laboratory could attempt. The claimed critical temperature was 400 K or more [[1]] — well above 300 K, which is room temperature, which is roughly the temperature of a warm afternoon in Seoul in July.

A video circulated almost immediately; it was attached to the six-author preprint [[2]]. A small, grey, irregular piece of LK-99 appeared to be partially levitating — tilting up, one end raised — above a permanent magnet. In the video it wobbles slightly, like something caught between gravity and an invisible hand.

Physics Twitter — I will use that name; it was still recognisably that in July 2023 — detonated. Within days of the listing, laboratories across the world were trying to synthesise LK-99. As I followed it, Discord servers formed and GitHub repositories appeared with shared synthesis protocols.

Within weeks, the evidence available to the field had converged against the claim.

I want to write about what happened in those weeks, because I think the episode is more interesting as sociology of science than as condensed matter physics. Phase-pure crystals were highly insulating and non-superconducting; Cu₂S transitions explained prominent transport anomalies in mixed samples, while small magnetic responses depended on sample composition. The rapid distributed scrutiny is genuinely remarkable, but no single impurity result explains every sample or social response.

Why Room-Temperature Superconductivity Is the Grail

Let me be precise about why this particular claim generates the response it does.

Superconductivity is the phenomenon in which certain materials, below a critical temperature, carry electrical current with exactly zero resistance. Not very low resistance — zero. A current established in a superconducting loop will, in principle, continue flowing indefinitely without any driving voltage. This is not a small quantitative improvement over ordinary conductors; it is a qualitatively different regime of physics.

Most established ambient-pressure superconductors still require cryogenic cooling. Many elemental superconductors have low transition temperatures; magnesium diboride, a conventional compound, reaches about 39 K [[4]]. The mercury-based cuprates exceed 130 K at ambient pressure [[5]], but cooling, materials engineering and critical-current limits still constrain applications.

Hydrogen-rich compounds reach very high reported transition temperatures under extreme pressure. The 287.7 K carbonaceous sulfur hydride claim was retracted in 2022 [[6]] and is not a valid record; independently established landmarks include H₃S near 203 K at about 155 GPa [[7]]. These are diamond-anvil-cell conditions, not an ambient-pressure cable technology.

Room-temperature, ambient-pressure superconductivity could be transformative if a material also supported useful current density, fields, manufacturability, stability and cost. Zero DC resistance would not eliminate grid conversion, contact or AC losses, and it would not by itself make maglev or MRI compact and affordable. Applications depend on properties absent from the phrase “room-temperature superconductor.”

This is why the response to the LK-99 preprints was not hysteria but rather the entirely rational behaviour of a community that understood exactly what was at stake if the claim were true.

What LK-99 Was and What It Claimed

LK-99 is chemically expressed as Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O, where x is approximately 0.9 to 1.1. It is a lead apatite — the same crystal family as the mineral in tooth enamel — with about one lead atom in ten replaced by copper.

The claim was not new in July. Lee, Kim and four co-authors had described LK-99 in a Korean-language paper in the Journal of the Korean Crystal Growth and Crystal Technology, received on 31 March 2023 and accepted on 18 April, as “the world’s first superconducting material surpassing the critical temperature of 97℃ at atmospheric pressure” [[8]]. It was the July preprints that reached an international audience.

The proposed mechanism, as sketched in the preprints, began with Cu²⁺ substituting for Pb²⁺. The three-author preprint gives the ionic radii as 87 pm for Cu²⁺ and 133 pm for Pb²⁺, so copper is about a third smaller, and attributes a slight shrinkage of the unit-cell volume, 0.48 %, to the substitution [[1]]. In its account the resulting stress distorts the structure and creates “superconducting quantum wells” at an internal interface; the six-author preprint instead invokes a one-dimensional chain and a “Brinkman–Rice–BCS” mechanism [[2]]. Neither preprint argues from flat bands. That picture came a week later, from density-functional calculations by Lai and colleagues and by Sinéad Griffin, which found narrow, isolated bands at the Fermi level [[9]] [[10]]. Flat bands are associated with strong electronic correlations that can, in principle, give rise to unconventional superconductivity, and Griffin pointed to moiré systems, the family that includes twisted bilayer graphene. That is a very different material — two carbon sheets stacked at a small “magic” twist angle — and it superconducts only at around 1 K (1.7 K at best in the original 2018 report) [[11]].

Reading the preprints in late July 2023 was, I confess, a slightly uncomfortable experience. The writing was rushed; the first version of the six-author preprint contains a word processor’s cross-reference error, in Korean, three times (“Error! Bookmark not defined.”) [[2]]. The preprints, from overlapping author lists in one group, were inconsistent in places. The six-author abstract claims a critical temperature above 400 K; its own resistivity section puts it at 104.8 °C, or 378 K [[2]]. That version says the sulfur “was evaporated during the reaction”, while the three-author version’s X-ray pattern shows “few Cu₂S impurities” [[1]], a detail that would matter within three weeks.

The resistance data did not show the zero the authors claimed. The six-author version says that below about 60 °C “the resistivity with noise signals can be regarded as zero” [[2]]. The three-author version reports bulk resistivities of 10⁻⁶ to 10⁻⁹ Ω·cm [[1]]: finite values, not zero; for scale, annealed copper at 20 °C has 1.7 × 10⁻⁶ Ω·cm [[12]]. Only for a thin film does it report 10⁻¹⁰ to 10⁻¹¹ Ω·cm, which it reads as meeting an international zero-resistivity criterion [[1]]. The synthesis protocol was described in enough detail to be reproducible, which was good, but the characterisation was incomplete in ways that mattered.

Red flags were present from the beginning. The tilted, wobbling video was not sufficient evidence for a Meissner state. Orientation and stability depend on field and sample geometry, and stable suspension can involve flux pinning; no universal horizontal pose follows from superconductivity. Magnetisation and zero-resistance measurements on phase-pure samples were needed.

And yet. The synthesis was simple. The claim was specific and testable. If there was even a small chance it was real, the imperative to check was overwhelming. So labs checked.

The Replication Wave

What happened over the following weeks was unusually fast and public for condensed-matter replication. This article does not establish that it was unprecedented.

Normally, a replication in physics looks like this: a group reads a paper, decides it is interesting enough to attempt, orders precursor materials, synthesises the compound (which takes weeks to months), characterises it with appropriate instruments (more weeks), writes up the results, submits them (more weeks), and eventually publishes — often six months to a year after the original claim, sometimes much longer. The feedback cycle is slow by design: slowness is a feature, not a bug, because it allows careful work rather than hasty work.

The LK-99 replication did not look like this.

Independent preprints were being submitted within a week of the listing (Fig. 1). Dates here and in the figure are arXiv submission dates; each preprint became public in a later listing, the 31 July submissions on 1 August [[3]]. The first was a calculation: density-functional theory from Lai and colleagues in Shenyang (29 July) [[9]]. Two of the next three were experiments, both submitted on 31 July, from Kumar, Karn and Awana in New Delhi and from Liu and colleagues in Beijing [[13]] [[14]]; the third, later that day, was a second calculation, by Griffin at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory [[10]]. Neither sample levitated, and the Beijing sample showed semiconductor-like transport with a room-temperature resistivity of about 2 × 10⁴ Ω·cm. German groups followed within three weeks (Thakur et al. in Dresden, 10 August [[15]]; Puphal et al. in Stuttgart, 11 August [[16]]).

Figure 1. Preprints explaining the half-levitation (day 12) and the resistivity jump (day 14) were submitted more than a week before Nature reported the consensus at day 22; among the preprints cited here, by arXiv submission date, claims of superconducting signatures end at day 9. Each mark is an arXiv v1 submission date from the arXiv API (for the news piece, its online publication date), counted from the listing of 25 July 2023; the small circle at day −3 is the originals’ submission on 22 July. Not shown: Habamahoro et al. (day 104) and the Korean review committee’s conclusion (day 141).

The furnace times show how fast that was. Kumar, Karn and Awana heated copper and phosphorus for 48 hours and the lanarkite mixture for 24, then the two products together for 10 hours at 925 °C [[13]]. With the precursors made in parallel that is 58 hours of heating, so a preprint submitted at 04:41 UTC on 31 July had its furnaces running by 18:41 UTC on 28 July at the latest, under four days after the listing. That is my arithmetic from their stated heating times; cooling, measurement and writing would push the start earlier.

As I followed it, Discord servers were organising synthesis attempts in real time, sharing thermograms, resistance measurements, and microscope images as they came off instruments. Twitter threads tracked emerging results with the urgency of a live event. A GitHub repository maintained by the community accumulated synthesis protocols, shared data files, and links to new preprints as they appeared. I have not reconstructed that informal record here; the dated preprints in Fig. 1 are the part of the wave that can be checked.

Some groups reported partial levitation: Wu and colleagues in Wuhan described crystals “which can be magnetically levitated with larger levitated angle than Sukbae Lee’s sample” (3 August) [[17]]. Others reported anomalous resistance drops: Hou and colleagues in Nanjing reported zero resistance up to about 110 K, far below room temperature (2 August) [[18]]. Others — from the first week — reported synthesising the material and finding nothing unusual at all.

The speed of this was extraordinary not because of any particular organisational effort, but because the incentive structure happened to align with the infrastructure that now exists. Preprints made sharing immediate. Social media made results public the moment they existed. The synthesis was simple enough to attempt in any reasonably equipped solid-state chemistry lab. And the motivation — the prize, if it were real — was enormous. You would not need to tell anyone to work on this. You would have to tell people to stop.

By mid-August 2023 — three weeks after the original preprints — the key debunking papers had appeared. By late August, there was no serious scientific debate remaining.

The Mechanism of Falsification

The levitating video was explained first, and the explanation is both mundane and instructive.

On 6 August, Guo, Li and Jia at Peking University reported “half levitation” of small flakes of their own LK-99-like samples on an Nd₂Fe₁₄B magnet [[19]]. Magnetisation measurements showed weak but definite soft ferromagnetism, which, together with the flakes’ pronounced shape anisotropy, they argued, is enough to stand a fragment on end in a strong vertical field. Their samples showed neither a Meissner effect nor zero resistance. Thakur and colleagues found “dark greyish flakes” that responded to a magnet in a way that imitated half-levitation [[15]]. Phase-pure crystals grown by Puphal and colleagues showed the diamagnetic response of a non-magnetic insulator plus a small ferromagnetic component, “possibly originating from frustrated exchange interactions in Cu-rich clusters” [[16]]. A tilted response to a permanent magnet is therefore not a unique signature of either superconductivity or one impurity mechanism.

The resistivity jump was explained two days later. The sulfur in the lanarkite route can end up in copper(I) sulfide, Cu₂S, and the three-author preprint’s own diffraction pattern had shown it. Bulk Cu₂S has a known solid–solid phase transition at about 104 °C, or 377 K [[20]], almost on top of the six-author preprint’s 104.8 °C. Zhu and colleagues measured Cu₂S directly and found the transition first-order: its resistivity fell from 13.7 Ω·cm at 385.6 K to 0.006 Ω·cm at 381.5 K, with a thermal hysteresis of 13.1 K between cooling and warming, and LK-99 samples containing Cu₂S showed the same sharp drop without reaching zero [[21]]. That is a factor of about 2,300 over about 4 K — dramatic on a logarithmic axis, and still not zero. The few kelvin between their temperature and Jain’s are expected: the transition shifts between heating and cooling and with the exact copper content of Cu₂₋δS [[20]] [[21]]. Habamahoro and colleagues later reproduced all the anomalies that Lee and colleagues had reported in electrical and magnetic measurements and associated them with the Cu₂S transition rather than superconductivity [[22]].

Null results accumulated alongside the explanations. Kumar and colleagues, in a second preprint, made phase-pure polycrystalline LK-99 and found it diamagnetic at 280 K with no sign of superconductivity [[23]]; Puphal and colleagues found their single crystals “highly insulating and optically transparent” [[16]]. Theory papers explored electronic structure, but calculations alone could neither verify nor falsify the experimental phase.

Non-superconducting polycrystalline and single-crystal samples from different groups supported the consensus against LK-99 superconductivity without implying that every anomaly or magnetic response in every mixed sample had one cause.

Dan Garisto summarised the consensus in a Nature news piece published on 16 August 2023 [[24]]: LK-99 is not a superconductor. The case was closed, with an efficiency that the scientific community should be proud of.

The Korean verdict came four months later. In December 2023 the review committee of the Korean Society of Superconductivity and Cryogenics, eight university research teams, reported that there was “no ground for saying that LK-99 is a superconductor,” and that the Quantum Energy Research Centre had not sent samples for cross-validation as promised [[25]].

A Useful Contrast: Ranga Dias

The LK-99 episode does not exist in isolation. The preceding years had seen other extraordinary claims of room-temperature or near-room-temperature superconductivity, and the most prominent involved Ranga Dias at the University of Rochester.

Dias was an author on two Nature papers claiming superconductivity at or near room temperature: carbonaceous sulfur hydride in 2020 [[6]] and nitrogen-doped lutetium hydride in 2023 [[26]]. Both were retracted, in September 2022 and November 2023. The journal records and associated notices, rather than the original claims, govern their publication status. The earlier Dias and Silvera metallic-hydrogen paper received an erratum in August 2017 and remains formally unretracted [[27]]; criticism is not the same metadata state as retraction.

The contrast is useful only up to a point. The public LK-99 record shows insufficient evidence for the claim and rapid independent testing; it does not let this article determine the authors’ private intent or moral state.

The Dias publications involve formal retractions and documented research-integrity proceedings [[28]], a different evidentiary record from a failed preprint replication. Retraction notices and institutional findings should be reported precisely; they do not license me to infer more than those records establish.

How do you tell them apart in real time? Both were claims of room-temperature superconductivity: the Dias papers in prestigious journals, LK-99 in a Korean-language journal and then on arXiv. In both cases, independent replication failed. The LK-99 falsification came faster, partly because the synthesis was simpler and partly because the community mobilised more broadly. The Dias case took years, and the data manipulation allegations required access to raw data that the research group was slow to provide: the susceptibility data at issue in the 2020 paper were posted more than a year after its publication [[29]].

I do not have a clean real-time test for intent. Observable indicators include data availability, cross-instrument consistency, independent replication and responses to requests for verification. Formal judgments about misconduct need the relevant investigative process, not an analogy between cases.

The Sociology of What Happened

Let me step back from the physics and say something about what the LK-99 episode reveals about how science actually functions.

The episode shows that community correction can be fast when a claim is sharply testable, many laboratories can attempt it and incentives are high. Preprints, social media and shared repositories accelerated exchange, alongside formal laboratories and publications. The counterfactual claim that this would once have taken two to five years is not measured here.

The preprints bypassed traditional peer review, letting both the claim and criticism circulate quickly. They were not the claim’s first publication, though: the Korean journal had accepted the April paper eighteen days after receiving it [[8]]. Its record gives those dates, not what the review involved. Journal review was not the mechanism that resolved the public claim on this timescale. Distributed experimental scrutiny provided a faster complementary process; it did not replace all functions of peer review.

This is not an argument against peer review. It is an argument that peer review in the traditional sense — two or three reviewers reading a manuscript over a few weeks — is not the only form that meaningful scientific scrutiny takes.

Social media’s role was ambivalent: it accelerated both the claim and criticism. I saw physicists identify red flags early, while some coverage foregrounded excitement over caveats. This post has no systematic sample from which to judge most physicists or journalists.

The Media, and the Calibration Problem

I want to be specific about the media failure, because I think it matters.

The appropriate headline on 25 July 2023, the day the preprints appeared in arXiv’s listing, was something like: “Korean researchers post preprints claiming room-temperature superconductivity; claim is extraordinary and unverified; replication underway.” That headline is accurate. It conveys the genuine excitement — because the claim, if true, would be extraordinary — while conveying the appropriate uncertainty about an unverified preprint from a single group.

Some coverage used discovery or “holy grail” framing. Without a linked corpus, the quoted wording should be read as illustrative rather than a prevalence claim. Calling an unreplicated preprint a discovery would misstate its evidence status.

This is a calibration failure — the same kind of failure I have written about in other contexts. On this blog, I have discussed how LLMs can fail catastrophically when they lack the context to assess whether their confident-sounding output is grounded in anything real (see the car-wash post, and more generally the discussion of context and grounding in more context is not always better). The mechanism in journalism is different but the structure is the same: confidence that is not appropriately calibrated to evidence.

The Bayesian structure is qualitative here. A rare, repeatedly misidentified phenomenon starts with low prior odds. The video and inconsistent preprints had plausible non-superconducting explanations and no independent replication, so their likelihood ratio was not established as large. They could raise a prior without warranting high confidence; this article supplies no numerical prior, likelihood or posterior. The same argument, applied to a film scene, is in the red-pill post.

A well-calibrated account would have said “claim, unverified, replication underway.” Many scientists urged that caution, while some researchers and headlines overinterpreted anomalies. A systematic calibration comparison between science and journalism is beyond the evidence assembled here.

This is not a new observation. Science journalists have been criticised for overclaiming since there have been science journalists. But the LK-99 episode is a particularly clean example because the timescale was so short: the calibration failure in the media and the calibration success in the scientific community happened simultaneously, in full public view, and could be compared directly.

I write occasionally about AI systems producing confident outputs that are not grounded in evidence (a theme that runs through recent posts on this blog). LK-99 is a reminder that poor calibration also occurs in human and institutional systems. The shared recommendation is to track confidence to evidence and update on data; the mechanisms and remedies differ across models, laboratories and newsrooms.

What the Scientific Community Actually Did

I want to be careful not to end on a note of pure cynicism about the media and leave the scientific community looking saintly. The community is not saintly.

There were preprints from independent groups that claimed positive results before the falsification was clear [[17]] [[18]]. There was social pressure, visible on Twitter as I followed it, to share exciting results before they were fully analysed. The Discord servers and GitHub repositories that, in my impression, were genuinely useful for coordination were also, occasionally, vectors for misinformation and premature interpretation.

Evidence converged against the claim through many attempts to verify or refute it, open discussion and later publications. That is the important result; not every contribution was reliable, open or coordinated.

I find this genuinely impressive. The LK-99 episode shows that correction can work quickly under favourable conditions. It does not establish a general rate or reliability for science.

Public scrutiny and replication complemented prepublication peer review; they are not evidence that all journal review could or should be replaced.

The Next Extraordinary Claim

The 2023 LK-99 superconductivity claim is rejected by the evidence reviewed here. Predictions about textbooks, credit or the authors’ careers would be speculation, so I will not use them as conclusions.

The question I am left with is what happens next time.

Further room-temperature-superconductivity claims are plausible in an active, high-reward field. Their truth cannot be assigned from the LK-99 episode, and a future false positive need not repeat the Cu₂S mechanism.

Will coverage improve? I am uncertain. Attention incentives can favour exciting framing, but this article does not measure newsroom incentives or individual journalists’ reasoning.

Will the scientific community respond as effectively? I think so, at least for claims of this kind: testable, synthesis-based, with enough labs in the world capable of attempting replication. The infrastructure — preprints above all, with Discord and shared repositories alongside — exists, and the dated preprint record shows it working. The speed of the LK-99 falsification sets a kind of benchmark.

The episode showed rapid correction under favourable conditions: a clear empirical claim, many capable groups and fast exchange. The original scientific claim failed, and parts of the communication amplified it. The later experimental correction is the success this essay is about.

Whether the media will have learned anything by the time the next extraordinary claim appears — that, I confess, I doubt.

References

[1] Lee, S., Kim, J.-H., & Kwon, Y.-W. (2023). The first room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor. arXiv:2307.12008 (v1 submitted 22 July 2023; preprint, not peer-reviewed). https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12008

[2] Lee, S., Kim, J., Kim, H.-T., Im, S., An, S., & Auh, K. H. (2023). Superconductor Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O showing levitation at room temperature and atmospheric pressure and mechanism. arXiv:2307.12037 (v1 submitted 22 July 2023; preprint, not peer-reviewed). https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.12037

[3] arXiv. (2023). Superconductivity (cond-mat.supr-con): New submissions for Tue, 25 Jul 23 and for Tue, 1 Aug 23. Archived by the Internet Archive on 25 July and 1 August 2023. https://web.archive.org/web/20230725224453/https://arxiv.org/list/cond-mat.supr-con/new and https://web.archive.org/web/20230801043915/https://arxiv.org/list/cond-mat.supr-con/new

[4] Nagamatsu, J., Nakagawa, N., Muranaka, T., Zenitani, Y., & Akimitsu, J. (2001). Superconductivity at 39 K in magnesium diboride. Nature, 410, 63–64. DOI: 10.1038/35065039

[5] Schilling, A., Cantoni, M., Guo, J. D., & Ott, H. R. (1993). Superconductivity above 130 K in the Hg–Ba–Ca–Cu–O system. Nature, 363, 56–58. DOI: 10.1038/363056a0

[6] Snider, E., Dasenbrock-Gammon, N., McBride, R., Debessai, M., Vindana, H., Vencatasamy, K., Lawler, K. V., Salamat, A., & Dias, R. P. (2020). Room-temperature superconductivity in a carbonaceous sulfur hydride. Nature, 586, 373–377. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-020-2801-z Retracted 26 September 2022: Nature, 610, 804. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-022-05294-9

[7] Drozdov, A. P., Eremets, M. I., Troyan, I. A., Ksenofontov, V., & Shylin, S. I. (2015). Conventional superconductivity at 203 kelvin at high pressures in the sulfur hydride system. Nature, 525, 73–76. DOI: 10.1038/nature14964

[8] Lee, S., Kim, J., Im, S., An, S., Kwon, Y.-W., & Auh, K. H. (2023). Consideration for the development of room-temperature ambient-pressure superconductor (LK-99). Journal of the Korean Crystal Growth and Crystal Technology, 33(2), 61–70. In Korean, with an English abstract. DOI: 10.6111/JKCGCT.2023.33.2.061

[9] Lai, J., Li, J., Liu, P., Sun, Y., & Chen, X.-Q. (2024). First-principles study on the electronic structure of Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O (x = 0, 1). Journal of Materials Science & Technology, 171, 66–70. DOI: 10.1016/j.jmst.2023.08.001 Preprint: arXiv:2307.16040, submitted 29 July 2023.

[10] Griffin, S. M. (2023). Origin of correlated isolated flat bands in copper-substituted lead phosphate apatite. arXiv:2307.16892 (v1 submitted 31 July 2023; preprint). https://arxiv.org/abs/2307.16892

[11] Cao, Y., Fatemi, V., Fang, S., Watanabe, K., Taniguchi, T., Kaxiras, E., & Jarillo-Herrero, P. (2018). Unconventional superconductivity in magic-angle graphene superlattices. Nature, 556, 43–50. DOI: 10.1038/nature26160

[12] National Bureau of Standards. (1966). Copper wire tables (NBS Handbook 100). DOI: 10.6028/NBS.HB.100

[13] Kumar, K., Karn, N. K., & Awana, V. P. S. (2023). Synthesis of possible room temperature superconductor LK-99: Pb₉Cu(PO₄)₆O. Superconductor Science and Technology, 36(10), 10LT02. DOI: 10.1088/1361-6668/acf002 Preprint: arXiv:2307.16402, submitted 31 July 2023.

[14] Liu, L., Meng, Z., Wang, X., Chen, H., Duan, Z., Zhou, X., Yan, H., Qin, P., & Liu, Z. (2023). Semiconducting transport in Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O sintered from Pb₂SO₅ and Cu₃P. Advanced Functional Materials, 33(48), 2308938. DOI: 10.1002/adfm.202308938 Preprint: arXiv:2307.16802, submitted 31 July 2023.

[15] Thakur, G. S., Schulze, M., & Ruck, M. (2024). On the synthesis methodologies to prepare Pb₉Cu(PO₄)₆O: phase, composition, magnetic analysis and absence of superconductivity. Superconductor Science and Technology, 37(1), 015013 (online 14 December 2023). DOI: 10.1088/1361-6668/ad1250 Preprint: arXiv:2308.05776, submitted 10 August 2023.

[16] Puphal, P., Akbar, M. Y. P., Hepting, M., Goering, E., Isobe, M., Nugroho, A. A., & Keimer, B. (2023). Single crystal synthesis, structure, and magnetism of Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O. APL Materials, 11(10), 101128. DOI: 10.1063/5.0172755 Preprint: arXiv:2308.06256, submitted 11 August 2023.

[17] Wu, H., Yang, L., Xiao, B., & Chang, H. (2023). Successful growth and room temperature ambient-pressure magnetic levitation of LK-99. arXiv:2308.01516 (v1 submitted 3 August 2023; preprint). https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.01516

[18] Hou, Q., Wei, W., Zhou, X., Sun, Y., & Shi, Z. (2023). Observation of zero resistance above 100 K in Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O. arXiv:2308.01192 (v1 submitted 2 August 2023). A revised version appeared as Hou, Q., et al. (2023). Synthesis, transport and magnetic properties of Cu-doped apatite Pb₁₀₋ₓCuₓ(PO₄)₆O. Matter, 6(12), 4408–4418. DOI: 10.1016/j.matt.2023.11.014

[19] Guo, K., Li, Y., & Jia, S. (2023). Ferromagnetic half levitation of LK-99-like synthetic samples. Science China Physics, Mechanics & Astronomy, 66(10), 107411. DOI: 10.1007/s11433-023-2201-9 Preprint: arXiv:2308.03110, submitted 6 August 2023.

[20] Jain, P. K. (2023). Superionic phase transition of copper(I) sulfide and its implication for purported superconductivity of LK-99. The Journal of Physical Chemistry C, 127(37), 18253–18255. DOI: 10.1021/acs.jpcc.3c05684 Preprint: arXiv:2308.05222, submitted 9 August 2023.

[21] Zhu, S., Wu, W., Li, Z., & Luo, J. (2023). First-order transition in LK-99 containing Cu₂S. Matter, 6(12), 4401–4407. DOI: 10.1016/j.matt.2023.11.001 Preprint: arXiv:2308.04353, submitted 8 August 2023.

[22] Habamahoro, T., Bontke, T., Chirom, M., Wu, Z., Bao, J. M., Deng, L. Z., & Chu, C. W. (2024). Replication and study of anomalies in LK-99—the alleged ambient-pressure, room-temperature superconductor. Superconductor Science and Technology, 37(4), 045004. DOI: 10.1088/1361-6668/ad2b78 Preprint: arXiv:2311.03558, submitted 6 November 2023.

[23] Kumar, K., Kumar Karn, N., Kumar, Y., & Awana, V. P. S. (2023). Absence of superconductivity in LK-99 at ambient conditions. ACS Omega, 8(44), 41737–41743. DOI: 10.1021/acsomega.3c06096 Preprint: arXiv:2308.03544, submitted 7 August 2023.

[24] Garisto, D. (2023). LK-99 isn’t a superconductor — how science sleuths solved the mystery. Nature, 620, 705–706. DOI: 10.1038/d41586-023-02585-7

[25] Byun, H.-j. (2023, December 13). LK-99 not superconductor, says Korean review committee. The Korea Herald. https://www.koreaherald.com/article/3281313

[26] Dasenbrock-Gammon, N., Snider, E., McBride, R., Pasan, H., Durkee, D., Khalvashi-Sutter, N., Munasinghe, S., Dissanayake, S. E., Lawler, K. V., Salamat, A., & Dias, R. P. (2023). Evidence of near-ambient superconductivity in a N-doped lutetium hydride. Nature, 615, 244–250. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-023-05742-0 Retracted 7 November 2023: Nature, 624, 460. DOI: 10.1038/s41586-023-06774-2

[27] Dias, R. P., & Silvera, I. F. (2017). Observation of the Wigner-Huntington transition to metallic hydrogen. Science, 355, 715–718. DOI: 10.1126/science.aal1579 Erratum: Science, 357, eaao5843 (18 August 2017). DOI: 10.1126/science.aao5843

[28] Garisto, D. (2024, April 6). Exclusive: official investigation reveals how superconductivity physicist faked blockbuster results. Nature (news). DOI: 10.1038/d41586-024-00976-y

[29] Dias, R. P., & Salamat, A. (2021). Standard superconductivity in carbonaceous sulfur hydride. arXiv:2111.15017 (v1 submitted 29 November 2021). https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.15017


Changelog

  • 2026-07-11: Removed a retracted hydride record; corrected levitation, Cu₂S, magnetic-response and replication claims; fixed Kumar et al. metadata; separated formal publication status from intent and bounded the sociology and media-calibration conclusions.
  • 2025-09-14: Updated the Cu₂S characterisation: pure Cu₂S is diamagnetic; the ferromagnetism in LK-99 samples comes from impurity phases. Updated the Dias & Silvera 2017 Science paper status: it received an erratum but was not formally retracted (unlike the 2020 and 2023 Nature papers). Updated the Senapati et al. reference to the correct LK-99 debunking literature (the previous arXiv ID resolved to a different paper).
  • 2026-10-03: Corrected the twisted-bilayer-graphene transition temperature (about 1 K, 1.7 K at best, not “well below 1 K”) and removed the claim that LK-99 had passed peer review at prestigious venues, which contradicted the article’s own account of the arXiv preprints. Removed two uncited references that could not be matched to a real record (“Liu & Meng”, arXiv:2308.05135, resolves to an unrelated paper; the Hirsch “Rejoinder” DOI resolves to a withdrawn Hirsch paper on ac susceptibility), and replaced “within a week … China, India, the United States, Germany” with the dated arXiv submissions that could be verified.
  • 2026-10-28: Corrected the dates: the preprints were submitted to arXiv on Saturday 22 July 2023 but first appeared in its public listing on 25 July (archived listing), so they no longer “appeared on arXiv” that Saturday, the “July 23” headline became 25 July, and the abstract now says two preprints were submitted that day. Replaced “within 72 hours … racing” with “within days” and removed “before the original authors had likely had a good night’s sleep”: the first independent preprint was submitted four days after the listing. Corrected the replication wave: Lai et al. (29 July) and Griffin (31 July) are density-functional calculations, not replications; by submission time the order was Lai, then the experiments of Kumar, Karn and Awana and of Liu et al. (no levitation; about 2 × 10⁴ Ω·cm), then Griffin. Reordered the falsification section so that the magnetic explanation of the half-levitation (Guo et al., 6 August) precedes the Cu₂S explanation of the resistivity jump (Zhu et al., 8 August, with their resistivity and hysteresis values; Jain, 9 August), as its first sentence says. Corrected the mechanism: the preprints proposed “superconducting quantum wells” and a one-dimensional mechanism, not flat bands, which came from the later calculations; in the preprint Cu²⁺ (87 pm) is a third smaller than Pb²⁺ (133 pm), not “slightly smaller” (the 0.48 % volume shrinkage is the slight part). Supported “rushed” and “inconsistent” with evidence: a Korean “Error! Bookmark not defined.” left three times in one preprint, its abstract’s critical temperature above 400 K against 104.8 °C in its own resistivity section, and sulfur said to have evaporated against the Cu₂S in the other preprint’s X-ray pattern. Made “not zero resistance” specific: the preprints claimed zero resistivity, but their bulk values are finite (copper given for scale). Corrected “293 K … a warm afternoon in Seoul in July” to 300 K (Seoul’s July mean daily maximum is 29 °C, 302 K), “neodymium magnet” to “permanent magnet” (neither preprint names it), “a fraction of the lead atoms” to about one in ten, “common precursors” to the actual starting materials and steps, and “Daniel” to Dan Garisto; replaced the cuprate value “roughly 138 K”, for which I could not open a source, with the verifiable “above 130 K”. Added the April 2023 Korean journal paper, accepted eighteen days after receipt, so “classical prepublication peer review was absent from the initial claim” no longer holds; the 2026-10-03 entry was right that no prestigious venue had reviewed it. The 2026-07-11 entry’s Kumar et al. fix left the ACS Omega paper (arXiv:2308.03544, four authors, 7 August) cited for the 31 July three-author preprint (arXiv:2307.16402); both are now cited, and the ACS Omega issue is 44, not 45. In the Dias section, added the retraction and erratum dates and the raw-data timing (posted more than a year after publication), and noted that LK-99 first appeared in a Korean-language journal. Removed a guess at the motives of the groups that reported positive results, now that they are cited by name, and marked the Discord, GitHub and Twitter accounts as my own observation. Added the Korean review committee’s December 2023 conclusion, the positive replication claims, a worked furnace-time estimate, Fig. 1 (timeline from arXiv submission dates), and numbered citations with 22 further references.