One of our strays discovered, sometime in her first winter indoors — they are strictly indoor cats now, on our vet’s recommendation — that she could fit into a salad bowl. Not sit beside it, not rest her head on its rim: fit into it, curled into a precise sphere with her tail tucked under her chin and her ears folded flat. The resemblance to a liquid filling a container was excellent.

The resemblance is also where the literal claim ends. A cat is an active, articulated animal, not a passive sample whose constitutive equation has been measured. Fortunately, the joke still contains real rheology.


The Timescale in the Joke

The intuitive distinction between solids and liquids is that solids retain a shape while liquids flow. Viscoelastic materials complicate this distinction: their response depends on how quickly they are deformed and how long they are observed. Silly Putty can creep on a table and fracture under a rapid impact. Mantle rock transmits seismic shear waves on a timescale of seconds yet flows over geological time.

The standard dimensionless ratio used to express this competition is the Deborah number,

$$\mathrm{De}=\frac{\tau}{T},$$

where $\tau$ is a characteristic material relaxation time and $T$ is the timescale of the process or observation. Marcus Reiner defined the number in an after-dinner talk at the Fourth International Congress on Rheology in Providence in August 1963, printed in Physics Today in January 1964 [[1]]. He invoked the prophetess Deborah’s line “The mountains flowed before the Lord”: even mountains can flow if the observer waits on an appropriately long timescale.

For a material and deformation with a well-defined relaxation time, $\mathrm{De}\ll1$ means stresses relax within the process time and fluid-like behaviour can dominate. At $\mathrm{De}\gg1$, stress persists over the process time and the response can look elastic or solid-like. Near unity, neither limit can be ignored. This is not a universal phase test. Real materials may have several relaxation times, and Deborah number alone does not specify the constitutive law, strain amplitude, or flow geometry.


A Model Where the Ratio Is Exact

The Maxwell model puts a linear spring of shear modulus $G$ (in pascals) in series with a viscous dashpot of shear viscosity $\eta$ (in pascal seconds); for the standard textbook treatment, see [[2]]. Both elements carry the same shear stress $\sigma$, and their shear strains add. The model has a single relaxation time,

$$\tau=\frac{\eta}{G}.$$

Under a constant shear stress $\sigma_0$ switched on at $t=0$, the shear strain is

$$\gamma(t)=\frac{\sigma_0}{G}+\frac{\sigma_0}{\eta}\,t. \tag{1}$$

The first term is the spring’s immediate elastic deformation; the second is unbounded viscous creep. In a stress-relaxation experiment, where a shear strain $\gamma_0$ is imposed at $t=0$ and then held fixed, the model instead predicts

$$\sigma(t)=G\gamma_0\,e^{-t/\tau}. \tag{2}$$

The stress per unit strain, $\sigma(t)/\gamma_0$, is the relaxation modulus; here it decays from $G$ to zero with time constant $\tau$.

Watch either experiment for a time $T$ and the Deborah number appears by itself. At $t=T$ the spring’s share of the creep strain in Eq. (1) is

$$\frac{\sigma_0/G}{\gamma(T)}=\frac{1}{1+T/\tau}=\frac{\mathrm{De}}{1+\mathrm{De}}, \tag{3}$$

and the fraction of the initial stress still present in Eq. (2) is

$$\frac{\sigma(T)}{\sigma(0)}=e^{-T/\tau}=e^{-1/\mathrm{De}}. \tag{4}$$

Both tend to one for $\mathrm{De}\gg1$, where to first order both equal $1-1/\mathrm{De}$, and to zero for $\mathrm{De}\ll1$. They do not get there in the same way (Fig. 1). The elastic share of the strain falls only in proportion to $\mathrm{De}$, while the remaining stress vanishes faster than any power of $\mathrm{De}$. If “fluid-like” means that less than 1% of the response is elastic, the relaxation experiment crosses that line at $\mathrm{De}\approx0.22$ and the creep experiment only at $\mathrm{De}\approx0.010$, a Deborah number about twenty times smaller.

Figure 1. The two responses of a Maxwell element agree above $\mathrm{De}\approx10$ and part company below $\mathrm{De}\approx1$: as $\mathrm{De}$ falls, the relaxation experiment loses its stress long before the creep experiment loses its elastic strain. Solid: elastic share of the creep strain at $t=T$, Eq. (3); dashed: stress remaining at $t=T$, Eq. (4); dots at $\mathrm{De}=1$ mark 0.5 and $e^{-1}\approx0.37$. The highlighted line is the invented illustration below ($\tau=5$ s, $T=600$ s). Maxwell model only; no cat data.

For this deliberately simple material, comparing $T$ with $\tau$ cleanly separates a short-time elastic response from long-time flow; only where the crossover is drawn depends on the experiment. Polymer melts, glacier ice, and geological materials require richer models, but the same discipline remains useful: state the material, deformation, and timescale before calling a response solid-like or fluid-like.


What Fardin Actually Did

Marc-Antoine Fardin’s “On the Rheology of Cats” is a short letter in the July 2014 Rheology Bulletin of the Society of Rheology, printed on pages 16–17 and continued on page 30 [[3]]. It applies this vocabulary to photographs of cats in containers and discusses Deborah number, wetting, yield stress, capillary break-up, and flow instabilities in the register of a technical paper. The application is intentionally comic. It earned the 2017 Ig Nobel Prize in Physics, awarded “for using fluid dynamics to probe the question ‘Can a Cat Be Both a Solid and a Liquid?’” [[4]].

His first figure opens with two cases. A cat rotating and bouncing, observed for under a second, has $\mathrm{De}\gg1$ and “appears as a solid material”; at longer times “a cat flows and fills an empty wine glass”, and $\mathrm{De}\ll1$. He continues: “From these preliminary experiments, knowing $T$ we can estimate the relaxation time to be in the range $\tau=1$ s to 1 min, for normal cases of Felis catus”, with values “as high as a few hours” for agitated kittens [[3]].

The paper did not report a programme of cat rheometry. It did not measure a feline relaxation spectrum, viscosity, elastic modulus, yield stress, or surface tension. Nor did it establish that an animal voluntarily changing its posture obeys the passive constitutive law of a fluid. Fardin flags this himself: cats are “active” materials that “have their own motive power”, which is why he finds their rate of deformation hard to define [[3]]. A cat settles into a bowl through muscles, joints, perception, and choice. Those mechanisms are exactly what a rheological material model leaves out.

That boundary matters because it preserves the useful part of the joke. A cat can illustrate how an observer’s timescale changes a description without becoming a Maxwell element.


An Arithmetic Illustration, Not a Measurement

Suppose, only for illustration, that I assign the bowl-settling performance a characteristic time of $\tau=5\,\mathrm{s}$ and watch for $T=600\,\mathrm{s}$. The ratio is

$$\mathrm{De}_\mathrm{illustration}=\frac{5\,\mathrm{s}}{600\,\mathrm{s}}=\frac{1}{120}\approx0.0083.$$

The arithmetic is correct. Its interpretation is conditional on an invented parameter: no experiment here shows that five seconds is an intrinsic relaxation time of this cat, independent of the bowl, temperature, mood, stimulus, or task. That it lies within Fardin’s range lends it no support, since his range is itself an estimate from “preliminary experiments”. Changing the assigned timescale changes the answer without revealing a feline material property. An earlier version of this article gave several cat times of my own invention; I have kept one worked ratio, labelled as an illustration.

Put into the Maxwell model, the number says that after ten minutes the spring holds $1/121\approx0.8\%$ of the creep strain, Eq. (3), and that $e^{-120}\approx7.7\times10^{-53}$ of an imposed stress remains, Eq. (4); this is the highlighted line in Fig. 1. Both are statements about a Maxwell element with $\tau=5\,\mathrm{s}$, not about the cat.

Likewise, dividing five seconds by a short contact time would produce a number much larger than one; Fardin’s bouncing cat, observed for under a second, is the same regime. That does not show that the cat undergoes a rheological phase transition during a jump. It shows that a dimensionless ratio inherits the quality of the quantities placed into it.


Where the Analogy Stops

The other rheological labels in Fardin’s paper work the same way. His yield-stress example is a kitten in a tilted jar that does not flow out because “it is below its yield stress, like ketchup in its bottle” [[3]]. The usual quantitative description of such a material is the Herschel–Bulkley law, which does not appear in his letter. Above yield,

$$\sigma=\sigma_y+k\dot\gamma^n,\qquad\sigma>\sigma_y,$$

where $\sigma$ is the shear stress, $\dot\gamma$ the shear rate, $\sigma_y$ the yield stress, $k$ the consistency (in $\mathrm{Pa\,s}^n$) and $n$ the dimensionless flow index; below $\sigma_y$ the material does not flow. The parameters are obtained from stress–rate measurements under defined conditions. A kitten in a jar, or a cat resisting relocation, has not thereby supplied $\sigma_y$, $k$, or $n$. Calling claws a yield transition is a punchline, not a fitted flow curve.

Capillary break-up is even more specific. Fardin captions a stretched cat “Extensional rheology of a cat before capillary break-up”. He makes the feline relaxation time a function of a “catpillary number” $\mathrm{Ca}\equiv\eta U/\gamma_{LV}$, where $\eta$ is the shear viscosity, $U$ a flow velocity and $\gamma_{LV}$, in his notation, the surface tension, and writes that surface tension “can be important and even dominant in the rheology, especially in CATBER (Capillary thinning and breakup extensional rheometer) experiments” [[3]]. CATBER is his pun on CaBER, the capillary break-up extensional rheometer. Such an instrument relies on the Rayleigh–Plateau instability, which his letter does not name either: surface tension makes a long liquid cylinder unstable, so a stretched filament thins and pinches off, and the rheometer reads the fluid’s properties from how fast it thins. The rebuttal is mine, not Fardin’s: a stretched cat has bones, skin, active control, and contact forces, and I see no reason to think surface tension is what thins it. Writing the instability’s dispersion relation beside the photograph would add formalism without establishing a shared mechanism.

No animal handling is needed to make either point. The photographs are enough.


Why the Deborah Number Still Matters

Outside cat physics, the ratio is useful precisely because researchers can define and measure the relevant material response. Reiner’s own example was a concrete bridge, whose expected time of service is to be compared with the relaxation time of concrete [[1]]. In polymer processing it helps compare molecular relaxation with a deformation time. In glaciology it helps distinguish rapid elastic or brittle response from long-term creep. In geophysics it helps explain why the mantle can transmit shear waves yet deform over millions of years. The numerical value remains model- and process-specific; “the Deborah number of this material” is incomplete unless the timescale and relaxation mode are identified.

The cat in the salad bowl therefore teaches two lessons. The first is Reiner’s: solid-like and fluid-like behaviour can depend on the clock. The second is more editorial: a dimensionless number does not turn an analogy into a measurement.

The material in the bowl is a cat.

Literature and calculations checked through 2026-10-25.


References

[1] Reiner, M. (1964). The Deborah number. Physics Today, 17(1), 62. DOI: 10.1063/1.3051374

[2] Barnes, H. A., Hutton, J. F., & Walters, K. (1989). An Introduction to Rheology (Rheology Series, Vol. 3), ch. 3, Linear viscoelasticity, pp. 37–54. Elsevier.

[3] Fardin, M.-A. (2014). On the rheology of cats. Rheology Bulletin, 83(2), 16–17, 30. Issue PDF, archived copy of the Society of Rheology’s file

[4] Improbable Research. (2017). The 2017 Ig Nobel Prize winners. In Past Ig winners. https://improbable.com/ig/winners/#ig2017


Changelog

  • 2025-12-15: Fixed Deborah number in summary from 0.08 to 0.008 (matching the body calculation: 5/600 = 0.00833).
  • 2025-12-15: Corrected Fardin’s institutional affiliation from “Paris Diderot University” to “ENS Lyon”; his affiliation on the 2014 paper is Université de Lyon / ENS Lyon.
  • 2026-07-11: Reframed cat rheology as Fardin’s deliberate analogy, removed invented feline material parameters and inapplicable instability claims, and retained one explicitly hypothetical Deborah-number calculation.
  • 2026-10-25: Corrected Fardin’s pages from 16–17 to 16–17 and 30, and linked an archived copy of the issue. Dated Reiner’s definition of the number to his 1963 congress talk, printed in 1964. Wrote strain as $\gamma$ throughout and the relaxation result as $\sigma(t)$, so that $G$ is only the spring modulus. Derived the elastic share of creep strain, $\mathrm{De}/(1+\mathrm{De})$, and the remaining stress, $e^{-1/\mathrm{De}}$, which fall below 1% at $\mathrm{De}\approx0.010$ and $0.22$ respectively, about twenty times apart, and plotted both (Fig. 1). Recomputed the worked ratio, $1/120\approx0.0083$ (unchanged), and read it through the model: $1/121$ of the strain elastic, $e^{-120}\approx7.7\times10^{-53}$ of the stress left. Added Fardin’s estimate of $\tau$, his “active” materials and “catpillary number”, the Ig Nobel wording and Reiner’s bridge. Defined the Herschel–Bulkley symbols and noted that Fardin names neither that law nor the Rayleigh–Plateau instability; the old “cat coiling in a narrow container” was not his capillary example. Shortened the body’s note on the invented cat times to one sentence. Numbered the references.