Summary

Jerome Bruner described three ways knowledge can be represented: enactive (bodily action), iconic (image), and symbolic (language and notation). They are a useful pedagogical lens, not a universal developmental staircase: a child can use symbols while action and imagery remain relevant to the task.

Maria Montessori developed her materials decades before Bruner’s formulation. Reading them as an implementation of his sequence is an analogy, not a claim of historical influence or a proof that one medium must dominate every learning outcome. A Golden Bead cube gives a child spatial and handling experience that an ordinary touchscreen does not reproduce.

This post asks what embodied-cognition research can and cannot tell us about choosing physical materials and tablets for a particular learning task.

Bruner’s Three Modes

Jerome Bruner proposed in a 1964 paper and the subsequent book Toward a Theory of Instruction (Bruner, 1964; 1966) that knowledge can be represented in three modes:

Enactive: Knowledge encoded in action patterns. You know how to ride a bicycle; you cannot fully describe it in words; the knowledge is in your body. An infant knows what “cup” means because she has grasped cups hundreds of times — before she has the word.

Iconic: Knowledge encoded in images or perceptual representations. You can visualise the route without navigating it. You recognise a melody without playing it.

Symbolic: Knowledge encoded in language or other arbitrary symbol systems. The numeral “7” has no visual resemblance to seven objects. Its meaning is purely conventional and rule-governed.

Bruner did present the modes as appearing in that order in childhood, action first (Bruner, 1964, as summarised by Byrne et al., 2023). The order describes emergence, not replacement: the cyclist in the example above is usually an adult, and her knowledge of the bicycle is still enactive.

Bruner did not supply a general rule that symbols acquired before action inevitably lack a referent, nor does the framework by itself predict a later transfer score. It does, however, motivate a testable instructional question: when does action, imagery, or symbol use help a given learner with a given concept?

Embodied-cognition research is a broad family of accounts and experiments, rather than a single settled instructional prescription.

What Embodied Cognition Actually Shows

Lawrence Barsalou’s 2008 review in Annual Review of Psychology is the canonical synthesis (Barsalou, 2008). The central claim: cognition is not computation on amodal symbols, independent of the brain’s modal systems for perception, action, and introspection; modal simulations, bodily states, and situated action underlie it. As an illustration, thinking about “lifting” would partly re-use the systems that lift. Concepts are grounded in the modal systems through which they were originally experienced.

This motivates a pedagogical hypothesis, not a demonstrated ranking of children or media. Physical objects can offer perceptual and motor information that a standard touchscreen lacks; whether that information improves arithmetic or measurement depends on the activity, instruction, learner, and outcome measured.

Arthur Glenberg and colleagues tested this experimentally (for his general case, see Glenberg, 2008). In a 2004 study, first- and second-graders read short texts, for example about a farm (Glenberg et al., 2004). Children who physically moved toy objects (a barn, a tractor, a horse) to enact the described events remembered and understood the texts markedly better than children who merely read and re-read the passages with the same toys in view. In Glenberg’s own later summary, they recalled 62% of the action sentences against 29% (Cohen’s d = 1.39). Imagining the moves, after practising them, also worked: d = 1.87 for recall and 1.50 for inferences (Glenberg, 2011). The physical action was not decorative. It was causally relevant to understanding.

Glenberg’s group then carried the method into arithmetic story problems. In one three-day classroom experiment, third- and fourth-graders moved pictures on laptop screens to act out stories, then imagined the moves while solving story problems. Against controls, the effect sizes were 0.54 for correct answers, 0.59 for correct solution procedures, and 0.78 for less use of irrelevant numbers; in the fourth grade the benefit appeared only on the third day, and the English-learner classes were assigned to the method rather than randomised (Glenberg et al., 2012). The enactive engagement was improving not just memory of the text but mathematical reasoning.

Whether the action has to be physical is a separate question, and the same programme bears on it. When children manipulated images on a computer screen instead of toys, the benefit over rereading (d = 1.16) was, in Glenberg’s words, “comparable to those found when manipulating the toys” (Glenberg, 2011). This suggests that what does the work is mapping words onto referents the child acts on; the heft of the objects was not tested.

Montessori Got There First

Maria Montessori opened the first Casa dei Bambini (“Children’s House”) on 6 January 1907 in a San Lorenzo tenement in Rome, at 58 Via dei Marsi, for the tenement’s children aged three to seven — “at the most, fifty children” to a school, by her own account (Montessori, 1912). She had no Barsalou. She had no Glenberg. She had children, materials, and the patience to watch what happened when children were allowed to choose their own work.

Her materials make the comparison to action, image, and symbol vivid, but Montessori did not build them from Bruner’s later framework and no system implements it “without exception.”

The Golden Bead Material is the canonical example. Units: single beads. Tens: ten beads wired into a bar. Hundreds: ten bars wired into a flat square. Thousands: ten squares wired into a cube. Montessori described the beads of her coloured bead bars as perle di vetro lucente, shiny glass, on stiff wire; for the decimal material she names only the colour (Montessori, 1916, pp. 394–395). The child can hold a unit bead between two fingers. She will probably take the thousand cube in both hands. The physical weight scales with place value. She experiences — proprioceptively — that “one thousand” is categorically heavier and larger than “one hundred” before she has seen the numeral or heard the word “thousands place.”

No maker I found publishes the cube’s mass; Nienhuis lists only its materials, glass and copper (Nienhuis Montessori, n.d.). Montessori’s bar of ten was “about 7 cm” long (Montessori, 1916, p. 395), and today’s plastic and acrylic beads are listed at 7 or 8 mm (IFIT Montessori, n.d.). By my estimate, a thousand glass beads 7 mm across, at about 2.5 g per cubic centimetre, weigh 0.45 kg before the wire, less if the beads are smaller, and 0.67 kg at 8 mm. The masses retailers list, 363 to 454 g, are all under half a kilogram (Montessori Outlet, n.d.; IFIT Montessori, n.d.). The cube weighs roughly half a kilogram, then, and the title rounds up by about a factor of two. The count is exact: a thousand unit beads.

The Knobbed Cylinder Blocks illustrate a different principle. Sets sold today have four wooden blocks; Montessori’s 1912 description has three, each containing ten cylinders varying in diameter, in height, or in both (Montessori, 1912). The child removes all cylinders and replaces them. The material does not stop her from making a mistake; it stops the mistake from going unnoticed. A cylinder too wide for a socket will not go in. If she drops one into a socket a little too large and goes on that way, she ends, in Montessori’s words, “with the big cylinder in his hand while only the smallest opening is empty”; in the block of equal diameters, a cylinder too tall for its socket projects beyond the top (Montessori, 1912, pp. 171, 193). The task cannot be completed incorrectly and left that way. Error control is mechanical, built into the material: “The didactic material controls every error.” The teacher need not intervene. The child corrects herself, alone, through the physical feedback of the materials.

Montessori called this controllo dell’errore — control of error — and counted the cylinders as its most mechanical form (Montessori, 1916, pp. 57–58). It is one of her most important insights: if the feedback is physical, the child internalises the standard rather than depending on external evaluation. The authority is in the material, not in the adult’s judgment.

Evidence on Montessori education is mixed in design and implementation, and cannot isolate every material or classroom practice. Angeline Lillard and Nicole Else-Quest published a landmark study in Science in 2006, using a lottery-based design: children who had won a lottery to attend public Montessori schools compared with those who had not (Lillard & Else-Quest, 2006). Montessori five-year-olds showed significantly higher letter-word identification, phonological decoding, and applied mathematical problem-solving. The lottery controlled for family self-selection. Like every randomised trial of public Montessori preschool before 2025, it was limited to one or two schools (Lillard et al., 2025).

A 2025 national randomised controlled trial followed 588 children who had entered admission lotteries at age three for 24 public Montessori schools (Lillard et al., 2025). At the end of kindergarten, in the intention-to-treat estimates, children offered a seat scored higher on reading (Woodcock–Johnson Letter-Word Identification, Hedges’ g = 0.30), executive function (0.25), short-term memory (0.29), and theory of mind (0.22). The mathematics estimate, the outcome closest to the golden beads, was smaller (Applied Problems, g = 0.17) and not statistically significant. Only 20% of lottery entrants consented to take part. The findings concern the programme tested: they do not show that handling any particular Montessori material causes every reported advantage, and the trial’s $13,127 lower cost per child holds for the districts studied, not for conventional programmes in general.

Korczak and the Right to Make Mistakes

Janusz Korczak ran a Jewish orphanage in Warsaw from 1911 and wrote How to Love a Child in 1919 (Korczak, 1919) and The Child’s Right to Respect in 1929 (Korczak, 1929). His central argument was that children are not pre-adults — they are persons with full moral status and a right to their own experience, including the experience of making mistakes. How to Love a Child names three rights: to death, to the present day, and to be what one is. Defending the first, Korczak wrote: “Fearing that death may snatch the child away, we snatch the child away from life; not wanting it to die, we do not let it live” (Korczak, 1919; my translation).

On 5 or 6 August 1942 German police came to his orphanage in the Warsaw ghetto. Polish friends outside the ghetto had offered to hide him or to provide false identity papers; he would not consider leaving. With Stefania Wilczyńska and the rest of the staff, he walked nearly two hundred children to the Umschlagplatz, the deportation site, and did not return. All of them were deported to their deaths at Treblinka (USHMM, n.d.).

I mention Korczak not as an appeal to emotion but because his argument is structurally connected to Montessori’s. If a child has moral status, she has the right to encounter the actual consequences of her choices — including physical ones. A material that lets her put a cylinder in the wrong socket and then shows her, physically, that it is wrong is a different kind of education from a screen that prevents error altogether through invisible software constraints, or one that simply supplies the correct answer. Montessori located the value in the same place: “it is precisely in these errors that the educational importance of the didactic material lies” (Montessori, 1912, p. 171).

Error is information. Physical error is particularly rich information. Taking it away is not protection — it is impoverishment.

Buber: What a Screen Cannot Offer

Martin Buber’s essay “Education,” delivered as an address in Heidelberg in August 1925 and published in Between Man and Man (Buber, 1947), argues that genuine education rests on what he calls a dialogical relation — the principle of his 1923 I and Thou, applied to teaching: an encounter in which the other is met as a whole, irreducible subject, not an object to be managed.

A touchscreen is the paradigmatic I-It relation. It is smooth, frictionless, optimised for engagement, responsive to exactly the touch it was designed to respond to. There is no otherness, no resistance, no genuine encounter. The screen does not push back. The Knobbed Cylinder Block does — literally. If you try to force a cylinder into the wrong socket, the material resists. That resistance is not a flaw in the pedagogical design; it is the pedagogical design.

Buber called the core of that relation Umfassung (Boventer, 1976), inclusion: the teacher stands at their own pole of the educational encounter and, “without forfeiting anything of the felt reality of his activity,” at the same time “lives through the common event from the standpoint of the other” (Buber, 1947, p. 97). Imagining the child, Buber adds, is not enough (p. 100). A screen cannot do this. It has no pole. Its responsiveness is a simulation of attention, not attention itself. Turkle’s later phrase for what chatbots offer, “pretend empathy” (Dizikes, 2026), makes a related point about machines that simulate care.

The Tablet Problem

The educational technology industry has produced an enormous quantity of “educational apps” for young children. The research is beginning to catch up.

Kathy Hirsh-Pasek and colleagues identified four pillars that distinguish educational from merely entertaining digital content: active, engaged, meaningful, and socially interactive learning, within the context of a supported learning goal (Hirsh-Pasek et al., 2015). They wrote when Apple’s App Store already listed 80,000 “educational” apps, “largely unregulated and untested,” and offered the pillars as a standard for judging them. An app that meets few of them produces interactions in the shallow sense — tapping, swiping — without the kind of self-directed, goal-oriented, socially-embedded activity that drives genuine cognitive development.

A 2021 meta-analysis of 36 intervention studies and 285 effect sizes, for children from preschool to grade 3, found a mean effect of educational apps of Hedges’ g = +0.31 on literacy and mathematics (Kim et al., 2021). The measure made most of the difference: predicted effects were g = 0.43 on researcher-developed outcomes against 0.17 on standardised tests, and effects were larger on constrained skills such as letter knowledge and counting. These were, the authors note, mostly high-quality apps, 92% of them used in school. The apps teach what they teach. Transfer is limited.

On the physical side, a 2023 scoping review of 102 studies found that physical manipulatives — block building, shape sorting, paper folding, figurine play — showed promising benefits, most clearly in mathematics, but the evidence was mixed and often limited by methodological shortcomings (Byrne et al., 2023). Its nine studies that compared physical with virtual manipulatives on the same content mostly found the physical versions no better, and two found the virtual ones better; for mathematics, the authors suggest, “the physical nature of the task may not be crucial,” while for some science concepts they found positive but limited evidence in favour of physical materials.

Haptics is one design difference, not a complete account of learning. A 2024 review of haptic technologies for children concludes that haptics “can potentially improve” early learning outcomes and names small samples among the drawbacks of the studies it covers (Hatira & Sarac, 2024); it does not establish that force feedback and texture substantially improve every listed outcome. Standard capacitive touchscreens generally do not simulate the weight, resistance, or material texture of the objects on screen, and none of the studies cited here tests weight as such.

The Golden Bead material supplies handling and scale cues that an ordinary tablet does not. That is a reason to preserve it where those cues serve the instructional goal, not evidence that the first tap violates a developmental law.

What We Should Ask

The question is not whether tablets have educational uses — they clearly do, particularly for older children working mainly with images and symbols, and for content where direct physical manipulation is impossible or dangerous. The question is whether we are using them where a child has not yet had the enactive experience that the symbols on the screen are meant to stand for.

A child who has carried the thousand cube across a room, stacked the hundreds into the square, and felt the weight difference has had a different experience of place value from one who has tapped numerals on a flat screen. Whether that difference improves delayed transfer is an empirical question for a specified task and assessment, not a result established here.

I would ask a narrower question before buying a tablet or a set of cylinders: what representation, feedback, social setting, and assessment does this particular concept require? Montessori materials may be a better choice when handling and self-correction are the point. Tablets can be useful for other tasks. Neither Bruner nor the haptics literature supplies a general verdict.

Literature and calculations checked through 2026-10-24.

References

  • Bruner, J. S. (1964). The course of cognitive growth. American Psychologist, 19(1), 1–15. DOI: 10.1037/h0044160
  • Bruner, J. S. (1966). Toward a Theory of Instruction. Harvard University Press (Belknap Press).
  • Barsalou, L. W. (2008). Grounded cognition. Annual Review of Psychology, 59, 617–645. DOI: 10.1146/annurev.psych.59.103006.093639
  • Glenberg, A. M., Gutierrez, T., Levin, J. R., Japuntich, S., & Kaschak, M. P. (2004). Activity and imagined activity can enhance young children’s reading comprehension. Journal of Educational Psychology, 96(3), 424–436. DOI: 10.1037/0022-0663.96.3.424
  • Glenberg, A. M. (2008). Embodiment for education. In P. Calvo & A. Gomila (Eds.), Handbook of Cognitive Science: An Embodied Approach (pp. 355–372). Elsevier. DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-08-046616-3.00018-9
  • Glenberg, A. M. (2011). How reading comprehension is embodied and why that matters. International Electronic Journal of Elementary Education, 4(1), 5–18. Article
  • Glenberg, A., Willford, J., Gibson, B., Goldberg, A., & Zhu, X. (2012). Improving reading to improve math. Scientific Studies of Reading, 16(4), 316–340. DOI: 10.1080/10888438.2011.564245
  • Montessori, M. (1912). The Montessori Method (A. E. George, Trans.). Heinemann. Scan
  • Montessori, M. (1916). L’autoeducazione nelle scuole elementari. Ermanno Loescher. Scan
  • Nienhuis Montessori. (n.d.). One Golden Bead Cube of 1000: Individual Beads (Glass) [product page, item 0085G0]. Retrieved 24 October 2026, from nienhuis.com
  • IFIT Montessori. (n.d.). Golden Bead Thousand Cube (C and W beads), Golden Bead Material (W Beads) and Golden Bead Bank Game (C Beads, 7 mm) [product pages]. Retrieved 24 October 2026, from ifitmontessori.ca
  • Montessori Outlet. (n.d.). Golden Bead Thousand Cube [product page]. Retrieved 24 October 2026, from montessorioutlet.com
  • Lillard, A. S., & Else-Quest, N. (2006). Evaluating Montessori education. Science, 313(5795), 1893–1894. DOI: 10.1126/science.1132362
  • Lillard, A. S., Loeb, D., Berg, J., Escueta, M., Manship, K., Hauser, A., & Daggett, E. D. (2025). A national randomized controlled trial of the impact of public Montessori preschool at the end of kindergarten. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 122(43), e2506130122. DOI: 10.1073/pnas.2506130122
  • Korczak, J. (1919). Jak kochać dziecko. Dziecko w rodzinie [How to Love a Child: The Child in the Family]. Towarzystwo Wydawnicze w Warszawie. Text
  • Korczak, J. (1929). Prawo dziecka do szacunku [The Child’s Right to Respect]. Wydawnictwo J. Mortkowicza. Text of the 1948 edition
  • United States Holocaust Memorial Museum. (n.d.). Janusz Korczak. Holocaust Encyclopedia. Retrieved 24 October 2026, from encyclopedia.ushmm.org
  • Buber, M. (1947). Between Man and Man (trans. R. G. Smith). Kegan Paul. (Contains “Education,” address delivered 1925, and “The Education of Character,” address delivered 1939.)
  • Boventer, H. (1976). Lernziel Freiheit: Das Erzieherische, herausgefordert durch die Emanzipationspädagogik. Aus Politik und Zeitgeschichte, B 28/76. PDF
  • Dizikes, P. (2026, September 29). Who we become when we talk to machines [on S. Turkle, Artificial Intimacy]. MIT News. news.mit.edu
  • Hirsh-Pasek, K., Zosh, J. M., Golinkoff, R. M., Gray, J. H., Robb, M. B., & Kaufman, J. (2015). Putting education in “educational” apps: Lessons from the science of learning. Psychological Science in the Public Interest, 16(1), 3–34. DOI: 10.1177/1529100615569721
  • Kim, J. S., Gilbert, J., Yu, Q., & Gale, C. (2021). Measures matter: A meta-analysis of the effects of educational apps on preschool to grade 3 children’s literacy and math skills. AERA Open, 7, 23328584211004183. DOI: 10.1177/23328584211004183
  • Byrne, E. M., Jensen, H., Thomsen, B. S., & Ramchandani, P. G. (2023). Educational interventions involving physical manipulatives for improving children’s learning and development: A scoping review. Review of Education, 11(2), e3400. DOI: 10.1002/rev3.3400
  • Hatira, A., & Sarac, M. (2024). Touch to learn: A review of haptic technology’s impact on skill development and enhancing learning abilities for children. Advanced Intelligent Systems, 6(6), 2300731. DOI: 10.1002/aisy.202300731

Changelog

  • 2026-02-03: Changed “lottery-based quasi-experimental design” to “lottery-based design” for Lillard & Else-Quest (2006). A lottery provides genuine random assignment; “quasi-experimental” implies the absence of randomisation, which is the opposite of what the lottery design achieved.
  • 2026-07-11: Corrected the article’s treatment of Bruner’s modes as a compulsory developmental staircase and of Montessori as a direct implementation. Narrowed claims about tablets, haptics, transfer, Montessori outcomes, and costs to what the cited evidence can support; retained the material-versus-screen comparison as a pedagogical recommendation.
  • 2026-10-03: Corrected the Hirsh-Pasek et al. (2015) pillar names and removed an unsupported claim that they reviewed apps and found most fail three or four pillars; corrected the Byrne et al. (2023) summary (mixed evidence, most promising in mathematics, not consistent transfer to standardised measures); removed the claim that imagined movement helped less than actual movement in Glenberg et al. (2004); replaced the unverifiable Turkle quotation with her documented phrase “pretend empathy”; corrected the Lillard & Else-Quest (2006) title and removed the incorrect “original German publication 1947” for Buber.
  • 2026-10-24: Added an estimate for the title, which nothing in the body supported: no maker publishes the thousand cube’s mass, and glass beads of Montessori’s size give roughly half a kilogram. Corrected the Korczak passage, which spoke of a material that “makes incorrect placement physically impossible”, contradicting the cylinder section and Montessori’s own account, and the phrase “where the enactive stage has not yet been established”, which contradicted the summary; added that Bruner did present the modes in a developmental order. Corrected the cylinder blocks (three in 1912, four today; in the equal-diameter block a misplaced cylinder protrudes rather than failing to fit), the Casa dei Bambini ages (three to seven), Barsalou’s “interoception” (introspection), with the motor and somatosensory sentences now marked as illustrations, Glenberg et al. (2004) (barn, tractor, horse; d up to 1.87, not “approached two standard deviations”) and Buber’s terms (a dialogical relation built on inclusion). Narrowed Korczak’s refused escape routes to what the USHMM reports (German police, nearly two hundred children) and added his three rights. Replaced the story-problem claim attributed to Glenberg (2008) with Glenberg et al. (2012), a laptop-based classroom experiment (effect sizes 0.54 to 0.78), and noted that on-screen manipulation worked about as well as toys. Corrected Kim et al. (2021): standardised outcomes showed a small effect (g = 0.17), not a negligible one. Removed an unverified claim about how many apps meet the Hirsh-Pasek et al. (2015) pillars. Added Byrne et al.’s (2023) finding that physical manipulatives were mostly no better than virtual ones in mathematics, and the 2025 trial’s effect sizes, non-significant mathematics result, 20% consent rate and cost figure.