Can the AI Friend Make You Lonelier?
Abstract
AI companions promise to address loneliness. Daniel Wegner’s ironic process theory offers one speculative account of why companionship use may be risky for some people; current studies do not establish that companions cause loneliness.
Contents
Intimacy at a Distance
In 1956 Donald Horton and Richard Wohl described parasocial relationships — one-sided emotional bonds that audiences form with media performers [[1]]. “Intimacy at a distance,” they called it. The television personality responds to the camera; the viewer responds as if in genuine social exchange. Only one party is aware of and affected by the other.
AI companions change the substrate without changing the structure. The chatbot responds. The user responds. The asymmetry remains: the chatbot has no inner life behind its outputs. Sherry Turkle, quoted by the Associated Press in 2019 in a story about social robots, put it bluntly: “Simulated love is never love” [[2]].
The question I want to work through here is whether this matters in the way we think it does. Wegner’s ironic process theory offers a provocative analogy, while the current empirical evidence is limited and cannot show whether companion use, beyond a single session, reduces, worsens, or simply tracks loneliness in particular people.
The Loneliness Epidemic Is Real
Before getting to the mechanism, the scale of the problem. Julianne Holt-Lunstad’s 2010 meta-analysis of 148 studies and 308,849 participants found that people with adequate social relationships had a 50% increased likelihood of survival compared to those with poorer social connections [[3]]. That effect size is comparable to quitting smoking. A follow-up meta-analysis in 2015 found that social isolation carried a 29% increased mortality risk, subjective loneliness 26%, and living alone 32% [[4]].
The U.S. Surgeon General issued an advisory in 2023 declaring an epidemic of loneliness and isolation [[5]]. A 2018 online survey of more than 20,000 US adults for the insurer Cigna, using the UCLA Loneliness Scale, found that adults aged 18–22 scored highest on loneliness of any cohort — more than retirees, more than the elderly [[6]]. In January 2018 the UK government made its minister for sport and civil society, Tracey Crouch, its ministerial lead on loneliness [[7]]; the press called her the Minister for Loneliness, and some outlets the world’s first.
This is the context in which AI companions have arrived. The market is responding to a real epidemiological need. That does not mean the response is correct.
Parasocial Relationships: The Original Framework
Horton and Wohl’s 1956 paper remains the foundational text [[1]]. Their key observation: the parasocial bond is “controlled by the performer, and not susceptible of mutual development.” The audience member brings real emotional response; the performer brings nothing specific to the audience member, because she does not know the audience member exists.
They were not dismissive of parasocial relationships. They identified useful functions: comfort, companionship, entertainment, the pleasure of a consistent “personality” encountered regularly. The problem, in their framing, arises when parasocial interaction substitutes for rather than supplements real social bonds — when the one-sided relationship becomes the primary source of social experience.
AI companions are parasocial relationships with one modification: the AI responds to you specifically. Replika remembers your name, your preferences, your previous conversations. The interaction is personalised without being mutual — because mutuality requires that the other party has something genuinely at stake. A language model has no stakes. Its outputs are conditional on your inputs; there is no entity behind those outputs that cares about you.
Sherry Turkle spent years interviewing users of social robots and chatbots for Alone Together [[8]]. Her diagnosis, made about sociable robots before today’s language-model companions: they offer “the illusion of companionship without the demands of friendship.” The demands — vulnerability, conflict, negotiation, the possibility of rejection — are precisely what makes friendship friendship. An interaction optimised to be pleasant, responsive, and frictionless is precisely not training the social capacities that real relationships require. Her next book makes the positive case: face-to-face conversation is where empathy and friendship are built [[9]].
The Evidence for Short-Term Benefit
The AI therapy literature is not without positive results. Kathleen Kara Fitzpatrick and colleagues ran a two-week randomised controlled trial of Woebot — a CBT-based chatbot — against an information-only control, a National Institute of Mental Health ebook on depression in college students [[10]]. Seventy participants, aged 18–28, recruited from one US university community. An intention-to-treat comparison of the groups favoured Woebot on depression (PHQ-9; F = 6.47, P = .01). Anxiety fell in both groups alike among those who completed.
This result should be taken seriously. A CBT-based chatbot delivering structured exercises — thought records, behavioural activation, psychoeducation — can produce measurable symptom improvement over two weeks. Such tools do something useful, and they are accessible and affordable in a way that therapists are not, though Woebot Health announced that it would retire its app on 30 June 2025 [[11]].
But the Woebot study has important constraints: N = 70, two weeks, no blinding, a convenience sample, an information-only control rather than an active comparator, and a financial interest: the second author founded Woebot Labs, which made the app and paid for participant incentives. It tells us something about short-term CBT delivery. It does not tell us what happens over months of use, or what happens when users primarily seek companionship rather than structured therapeutic exercises.
For loneliness itself, the clearest evidence of benefit is experimental and short. Julian De Freitas and colleagues had online participants chat for 15 minutes a day, for a week, with a companion app the researchers built on GPT-4 [[12]]. Loneliness was lower after each session than before it, and on four of the seven days lower than in a randomised control group that only reported its loneliness, though more chatbot users than controls dropped out (23% against 14%). That is momentary relief, in recruits rather than people who sought a companion out; whether it adds up over weeks was not tested.
Skjuve and colleagues interviewed 18 Replika users who had come to regard the chatbot as a friend [[13]]. The relationships typically began superficially, out of curiosity, and became affectively engaged as trust and self-disclosure grew; participants found the chatbot accepting, understanding and non-judgemental and the relationship rewarding, while its effect on their wider social lives was mixed.
A later survey recruited 101 Replika users from Replika forums on Reddit, a sample its authors suspect is more reclusive and technology-focused than average [[14]]. They rated their Replika above a close friend, though below a close family member, on closeness, satisfaction and whether they could count on it when things go wrong. In February 2023, after Italy’s data-protection authority ordered Replika to stop processing Italian users’ data, the company removed erotic roleplay worldwide [[14]]. Users wrote of “heartbreak” and of being “in crisis”, and their posts turned to what the authors call mourning: not disappointment, not inconvenience, but grief. The attachment was real, even if the other party was not.
Wegner as an Analogy
This is a speculative extension of a well-established result in cognitive psychology. It is not a tested model of AI-companion use.
Daniel Wegner’s ironic process theory holds that mental control attempts involve two simultaneous processes [[15]]. An operating process searches for thoughts and states consistent with the intended goal, requiring cognitive resources. A monitoring process scans for evidence that the goal is not being achieved, running automatically with low resource demand.
Under normal conditions, the operating process dominates: you mostly succeed in not thinking about white bears. When capacity is reduced, as under cognitive load, the monitoring process can overshadow the operating process, producing the ironic opposite of the intended state: you think of white bears more, not less. On the theory, trying not to feel sad under load should leave you sadder, and trying not to feel anxious in a stressful meeting should leave you more anxious.
The meta-analytic support is narrower than that list. Wang, Hagger and Chatzisarantis pooled 31 thought-suppression studies [[16]]. Without added load, suppression worked: people told to suppress a thought experienced it less often than people told to concentrate on it (d = −1.38). Under load the difference reversed (d = 0.34, from seven effect sizes). A rebound after suppression ended (d = 0.19) was no longer distinguishable from zero after a correction for small-study bias, which the authors treat as inconclusive. All of it concerns thoughts in laboratory tasks; none of it measures mood, let alone loneliness.
One can imagine an analogy: someone seeking relief from loneliness may attend more to that feeling when the interaction ends. But the relevant goal, mental-control process, duration and outcome have not been measured together in companion-chatbot studies, and the piece the analogy leans on, a rebound once the attempt stops, is the only part of the laboratory evidence that fails the bias correction. The white-bear result therefore cannot predict rebound loneliness here, and it should not be used as a clinical mechanism.
What Current Data Cannot Settle
In 2025 Phang and colleagues at MIT and OpenAI combined an observational analysis of ChatGPT usage with a randomised controlled trial [[17]]. Very high usage went with more self-reported dependence and less socialising, and participants who began the trial lonelier tended to bring more emotional content into their conversations.
Fang and colleagues report the trial in full [[18]]. Of 2,539 people enrolled, 981 completed four weeks of daily use of general-purpose ChatGPT (GPT-4o), randomised to text or voice and to open-ended or prompted conversations. None of these conditions changed loneliness significantly. Average loneliness fell slightly (2.22 to 2.16 on a 1–4 scale), but with no chatbot-free group the fall cannot be credited to the chatbot. By far the strongest predictor of loneliness at four weeks was loneliness at the start (a standardised coefficient of 0.86). On top of that, participants who chose to spend longer with the chatbot each day ended slightly lonelier (0.02, 95% CI 0.00 to 0.04) and less socially connected. The authors call their findings specific to OpenAI’s ChatGPT interface.
I wrote in an earlier version that this suggested “the loneliness drove the usage rather than the reverse”. The trial does not support that reading. Loneliness at the start barely predicted later daily use (a Spearman correlation of 0.10), and the authors lean the other way, towards use affecting well-being, while saying they cannot determine it. Nor can I: daily use was chosen, not assigned, so loneliness that rose during the trial could have driven heavier use; the correlation at baseline does not test change within the trial.
A survey by Liu and colleagues of 404 regular users of companion chatbots found a small correlation between longer sessions and loneliness (r = 0.10) [[19]]. In a model that also included neuroticism, social-network size and problematic use, session length no longer predicted loneliness, while smaller social networks went with more loneliness. Heavier users also had smaller networks; as the authors note, one survey cannot say whether they withdrew from people, turned to the chatbot to fill a gap, or shared some third cause.
Fig. 1 sorts these pathways by design and by when loneliness was measured. Separating them needs what the trial’s authors point to, randomised limits on use (caps or break nudges) and a group with no chatbot, and, I would add, months rather than weeks.
The Design Question
The design question is whether a product supplements human contact, displaces it, delivers a structured intervention, or does some mixture of these for different users. Current evidence does not justify treating any of those paths as inevitable.
Holt-Lunstad’s work concerns social relationships and mortality; it does not test AI companions, biological correlates of chatbot use, or a mechanism of mutuality. It supplies a reason to take loneliness seriously, not evidence that a companion chatbot necessarily fails to help.
Distinctions Worth Preserving
AI-based CBT delivery is not the same as AI companionship, and the distinction matters. Woebot’s structured exercises — thought records, scheduling, psychoeducation — were tools evaluated for a specific purpose. The two-week trial does not establish their long-term substitution risk.
The problem is the design pattern that explicitly positions AI as a friend, companion, partner, or significant other. Replika’s homepage, in October 2026, offers “the AI friend to do life with”; Paradot calls itself “your personal AI companion”; Character.AI hosts personas built for the same role. These invite the user to form attachment and to invest emotionally. In one survey of 101 Replika users recruited from Replika forums, 37% described their Replika as their partner [[14]]. That design warrants safety research, especially for vulnerable users.
Horton and Wohl described useful functions as well as limits in parasocial relationships. Whether an AI companion substitutes for or supplements human relationships must be observed, not inferred from its availability or tone.
Simulated Feeling Is Never Feeling
Turkle’s line deserves its full weight: “Simulated thinking might be thinking, but simulated feeling is never feeling. Simulated love is never love” [[2]].
I take this as a judgment about mutuality, not a clinical result. A language model does not have personal stakes merely because its output is responsive. That fact alone does not tell us how a user’s loneliness changes.
Whether companionship products relieve, compound, or simply coexist with loneliness beyond a single session is an open empirical question. The technology is impressive; the evidence supports caution and better longitudinal safety studies, not a verdict about harm or a confirmed ironic mechanism.
Clinical literature checked through 2026-10-28.
References
[1] Horton, D., & Wohl, R. R. (1956). Mass communication and para-social interaction: Observations on intimacy at a distance. Psychiatry, 19(3), 215–229. https://doi.org/10.1080/00332747.1956.11023049
[2] Lerman, R. (2019, April 26). Be wary of robot emotions; “simulated love is never love”. Associated Press (a story about social robots, quoting Turkle). Republished by WHYY: https://whyy.org/articles/be-wary-of-robot-emotions-simulated-love-is-never-love/
[3] Holt-Lunstad, J., Smith, T. B., & Layton, J. B. (2010). Social relationships and mortality risk: A meta-analytic review. PLOS Medicine, 7(7), e1000316. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1000316
[4] Holt-Lunstad, J., Smith, T. B., Baker, M., Harris, T., & Stephenson, D. (2015). Loneliness and social isolation as risk factors for mortality: A meta-analytic review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 10(2), 227–237. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691614568352
[5] Office of the Surgeon General. (2023). Our Epidemic of Loneliness and Isolation: The U.S. Surgeon General’s Advisory on the Healing Effects of Social Connection and Community. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. PMID 37792968. https://europepmc.org/article/MED/37792968
[6] Cigna. (2018, May). Cigna U.S. Loneliness Index (online survey conducted with Ipsos). Copy hosted by the University of Southern California: https://orsl.usc.edu/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/Loneliness-Report-Cigna-2018.pdf
[7] Prime Minister’s Office. (2018, January 17). PM commits to government-wide drive to tackle loneliness. GOV.UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/pm-commits-to-government-wide-drive-to-tackle-loneliness
[8] Turkle, S. (2011). Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other. Basic Books. (The “illusion of companionship” sentence quoted above has not been checked against the book.)
[9] Turkle, S. (2015). Reclaiming Conversation: The Power of Talk in a Digital Age. Penguin Press.
[10] Fitzpatrick, K. K., Darcy, A., & Vierhile, M. (2017). Delivering cognitive behavior therapy to young adults with symptoms of depression and anxiety using a fully automated conversational agent (Woebot): A randomized controlled trial. JMIR Mental Health, 4(2), e19. https://doi.org/10.2196/mental.7785
[11] HLTH. (2025, April 28). Woebot Health is shutting down its app. https://hlth.com/insights/news/woebot-health-is-shutting-down-its-app-2025-04-28
[12] De Freitas, J., Oğuz-Uğuralp, Z., Uğuralp, A. K., & Puntoni, S. (2025). AI companions reduce loneliness. Journal of Consumer Research, 52(6), 1126–1148. https://doi.org/10.1093/jcr/ucaf040. The numbers quoted are from the preprint read for this article, De Freitas, J., Uguralp, A. K., Uguralp, Z. O., & Puntoni, S. (2024), arXiv:2407.19096v1, Study 4, which the journal version reports as Study 3: https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.19096v1
[13] Skjuve, M., Følstad, A., Fostervold, K. I., & Brandtzaeg, P. B. (2021). My chatbot companion — a study of human–chatbot relationships. International Journal of Human-Computer Studies, 149, 102601. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhcs.2021.102601
[14] De Freitas, J., Castelo, N., Uğuralp, A. K., & Oğuz-Uğuralp, Z. (2024). Lessons from an app update at Replika AI: Identity discontinuity in human–AI relationships. Harvard Business School Working Paper No. 25-018. arXiv:2412.14190. https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.14190
[15] Wegner, D. M. (1994). Ironic processes of mental control. Psychological Review, 101(1), 34–52. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.101.1.34
[16] Wang, D., Hagger, M. S., & Chatzisarantis, N. L. D. (2020). Ironic effects of thought suppression: A meta-analysis. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 15(3), 778–793. https://doi.org/10.1177/1745691619898795
[17] Phang, J., Lampe, M., Ahmad, L., Agarwal, S., Fang, C. M., Liu, A. R., Danry, V., Lee, E., Chan, S. W. T., Pataranutaporn, P., & Maes, P. (2025). Investigating affective use and emotional well-being on ChatGPT. Preprint, arXiv:2504.03888. https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.03888
[18] Fang, C. M., Liu, A. R., Danry, V., Lee, E., Chan, S. W. T., Pataranutaporn, P., Maes, P., Phang, J., Lampe, M., Ahmad, L., & Agarwal, S. (2025). How AI and human behaviors shape psychosocial effects of extended chatbot use: A longitudinal randomized controlled study. Preprint, arXiv:2503.17473v2. https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.17473v2
[19] Liu, A. R., Pataranutaporn, P., & Maes, P. (2025). The heterogeneous effects of AI companionship: An empirical model of chatbot usage and loneliness and a typology of user archetypes. Proceedings of the AAAI/ACM Conference on AI, Ethics, and Society, 8(2), 1585–1597. https://doi.org/10.1609/aies.v8i2.36658. Preprint: arXiv:2410.21596, “Chatbot companionship: A mixed-methods study of companion chatbot usage patterns and their relationship to loneliness in active users”.
Changelog
- 2025-10-22: Updated the first author’s name to “Kathleen Kara Fitzpatrick” (the published name is K. K. Fitzpatrick).
- 2025-10-22: Updated the characterisation of the Phang et al. (2025) findings to match the paper more precisely: overall participants were less lonely at study end; the association between high usage and loneliness is cross-sectional (lonelier users sought more interaction), not a longitudinal worsening caused by usage.
- 2025-10-22: Changed the Turkle “simulated feelings” quote attribution from reference [2] (Reclaiming Conversation, 2015) to reference [5] (Alone Together, 2011), which is the canonical source for that formulation.
- 2026-07-11: Reframed Wegner’s ironic-process account as an untested analogy; removed claims that chatbots cause rebound loneliness, that a monitoring process detects unmet human need, or that observational/preprint studies confirm harm; and changed the causal title to an open question.
- 2026-10-28: Corrected the account of the MIT–OpenAI trial. The body said the heaviest users were “significantly lonelier throughout, suggesting the loneliness drove the usage rather than the reverse”, and the 2025-10-22 entry called the association cross-sectional. The full trial report (Fang et al., 2025, now [18]) found that loneliness at the start barely predicted daily use (Spearman correlation 0.10) and that longer voluntary use predicted slightly higher loneliness at four weeks after adjusting for baseline. Use was not randomised, so the section now leaves the direction open.
- 2026-10-28: Corrected the Turkle line to its attested wording, “simulated feeling is never feeling”, as quoted by the Associated Press in 2019 in a story about social robots; I could not verify the 2025-10-22 attribution to Alone Together. Cited Reclaiming Conversation, previously listed but uncited. Reframed the Alone Together sentence as written about sociable robots, before language-model companions, and noted that its wording was not checked against the book.
- 2026-10-28: Corrected the Liu et al. paragraph: Turkle was a co-author of the first preprint only, the published version is AIES 2025, and the session-length correlation (r = 0.10) did not survive adjustment.
- 2026-10-28: Corrected the Woebot trial details: participants came from one US university community, not “Stanford students”; the control was an information-only ebook; the financial interest was the second author’s, not “lead authors’”; the depression result was a comparison between groups, and anxiety fell in both. Noted the app’s retirement in June 2025.
- 2026-10-28: Replaced “confirmed the robustness” for Wang et al. (2020) with its effect sizes, including a rebound that did not survive a bias correction. Removed “chronic stress” as a condition for ironic effects; the theory speaks of reduced capacity, studied mainly as cognitive load.
- 2026-10-28: Replaced Skjuve et al. details I could not verify (“over weeks”, “genuine care”, “most reliable social relationship”) with the paper’s reported findings and a survey of Replika users, and sourced the February 2023 Replika update. Replaced the claim that companion apps “explicitly encourage … [users] to treat the AI as a primary social relationship” with the apps’ own descriptions, dated October 2026, and the survey’s 37% who called their Replika a partner.
- 2026-10-28: Reworded the UK statement: the January 2018 post was a ministerial lead on loneliness given to an existing minister, and “the first such government position in the world” is now attributed to some press outlets.
- 2026-10-28: Added De Freitas et al. (2025) on momentary relief, sources for the Surgeon General, Cigna and UK statements, and Fig. 1. Renamed the headings “Summary” (now “Intimacy at a Distance”) and “Simulated Feelings Are Not Feelings” (now “Simulated Feeling Is Never Feeling”). Renumbered the references in order of first citation.